See what's new

Testlify
Skill assessment
Last updated on: 12 November 202615 min read

How to identify high potential employees: signs, tools and steps

A practical guide to spotting future leaders in your team: the signs of potential, the tools HR teams use and a step-by-step process.

How to identify high potential employees: signs, tools and steps

Your next head of department may already be on your team, doing solid work in a role that hides what they could do. Knowing how to identify high potential employees means telling potential apart from performance, because many teams promote on past results and gut feel.

Potential is the capacity to succeed in a bigger role, while performance is how well someone does today's job. Below are the signs to look for, the tools that work and a 6-step process to check potential with evidence.

TL;DR:

  • A high potential employee performs well now and has the ability, aspiration and engagement to handle a much larger role within years.
  • Potential is not performance: a top performer in today's role may not succeed two levels up. Check the capabilities the next role needs.
  • Look for learning agility, strategic thinking, influence, composure under ambiguity, ownership and growth drive, shown over several months.
  • Identify them in 6 steps: define potential, agree the evidence, collect nominations, add assessments, test with stretch work and calibrate in a talent review.
  • Combine three or four tools, such as the 9-box grid, 360 feedback, skills assessments and stretch assignments. No single tool is enough.
  • Retention risk is rising: DDI found high potentials planning to leave within a year rose from 13% in 2020 to 21% in 2024.
  • Give each one a development plan, a senior sponsor and stretch work, and review the list every 12 months.
Summarise this post with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

What is a high potential employee?

A high potential employee is someone who performs well now and has the ability, aspiration and engagement to take on a much larger role within a few years. Most organizations keep high potentials to a small group and invest extra development in them, so the label has to be earned with evidence.

The three parts of that definition matter because each one can be missing on its own:

  • Ability: the reasoning, learning speed and people skills to handle more complexity.
  • Aspiration: the person actually wants a bigger role, more responsibility or a leadership track.
  • Engagement: the person is committed to the organization and likely to stay long enough for the investment to pay off.

An employee with ability but no aspiration is a valued expert, not a high potential. An employee with aspiration but no ability needs development before the label fits.

The word "high potential" only works when all three show up together and the evidence for each is written down.

Build your dream team — Book a product demo

How is high potential different from high performance?

High potential is about future capacity; high performance is about current results. A high performer reliably hits targets in their present role.

A high potential employee may or may not be the top performer today, but shows the learning speed and judgment to succeed in a role that is broader, more ambiguous and more senior.

Most high potentials are also strong performers, but the reverse is not true. Confusing the two is the most common reason organizations promote a great individual contributor into a management role and watch them struggle.

Factor

High performer

High potential employee

Main question

How well do they do this job?

How well could they do a bigger job?

Evidence

Goals met, quality of work, KPIs

Learning agility, judgment in new situations, influence, stretch results

Time frame

Past and present

Next 2 to 5 years

Best measured by

Performance reviews, output data

Assessments, stretch assignments, 360 feedback, talent reviews

Risk if misread

Promoted into a role that needs different skills

Overlooked because results look average in a poor-fit role

Development need

Depth in the current role

Breadth, exposure and leadership experience

A useful test in a talent review is to ask, "What would this person need to succeed two levels up, and what evidence do we have that they can learn it?" If the only evidence is this year's results, you are looking at performance, not potential.

Why does identifying high potential employees matter now?

Identifying high potential employees matters because the people most likely to become your future leaders are also the most likely to leave. DDI's Global Leadership Forecast 2025, based on 2,185 HR professionals and 10,796 leaders, found that high potential individual contributors planning to leave within a year rose from 13% in 2020 to 21% in 2024.

The same DDI report found that only 20% of HR professionals felt confident in their leadership bench in 2024. Organizations that cannot name their next leaders end up hiring externally for critical roles, which is slower and riskier than promoting someone who already knows the business.

Manager capacity makes the problem harder. Most HiPo programs rely on managers to nominate and develop people, yet Gallup's 2026 State of the Global Workplace data puts manager engagement at just 22% for 2025, with global employee engagement at 20%.

Disengaged managers are less likely to spot quiet talent or argue for it in a talent review.

That is why a structured, evidence-based process beats an annual list of names. It gives HR a consistent way to find potential across teams, not only in the teams with the most vocal managers.

What are the signs of a high potential employee?

The signs of a high potential employee are behaviors you can observe and test, not personality traits or a hunch. Look for patterns that repeat over several months, not one strong project. Six signs matter most, grouped into learning, leading and driving, and each one is covered below.

Six signs of high potential employees grouped into learning, leading and driving
  1. Learning agility: Picks up unfamiliar work quickly and applies lessons from one situation to the next. Our guide to learning agility covers how to assess it.
  2. Strategic thinking: Connects their work to team and business goals, and asks why a task matters before asking how to do it.
  3. Influence: Peers seek them out for advice; they bring people from other teams along without needing a title.
  4. Composure under ambiguity: Stays productive when there is no playbook, priorities change or a project goes wrong.
  5. Ownership and initiative: Spots problems outside their remit and fixes them or raises them with a plan.
  6. Growth drive: Asks for feedback, volunteers for stretch work and talks about where they want to be in 3 years.

SHRM's guidance on spotting potential beyond performance metrics adds a practical point: keep a written record of how people handle setbacks, cross-functional work and new skills over time, so the evidence exists before the talent review.

How to identify high potential employees in 6 steps

To identify high potential employees, define what potential means for your critical roles, agree on the evidence before anyone is nominated, gather manager nominations against that definition, add objective assessments, test people with stretch assignments, and calibrate the final list in a cross-team talent review. Then review it every year.

How to identify high potential employees in 6 steps, from defining potential to calibrating in a talent review

Step 1: Define potential for the roles you need to fill

Start from the business, not from a list of traits. Which leadership and specialist roles will you need to fill in the next 3 to 5 years?

List the 4 to 6 capabilities those roles need. Tie this to your succession planning so the HiPo list feeds real roles.

Step 2: Agree on the evidence before anyone is nominated

For each capability, decide what counts as proof: an assessment score band, a stretch result, 360 ratings or specific examples. Writing this down first stops the process from rewarding whoever is most visible.

Step 3: Collect manager nominations against the definition

Ask managers to nominate people and attach evidence for each capability. Ask them to consider people outside their own team and people who are quiet but consistent.

Train managers on the difference between performance and potential before nominations open.

Step 4: Add objective assessments

Use the same assessments for every nominee: a learning agility test, a cognitive or critical thinking test, a situational judgment test and a leadership potential test are common choices. Scores show where manager views and data disagree, which is exactly where the useful conversations happen.

Step 5: Test potential with a stretch assignment

Give shortlisted people a project one level above their role, such as leading a cross-functional initiative or covering for a manager. How someone handles a real stretch is stronger evidence than any rating.

Step 6: Calibrate in a talent review

Bring managers and HR together to compare nominees across teams using the same evidence. Many teams place people on a 9-box matrix at this stage.

Our guide to running a talent review covers the session itself.

Pro tip: Review the list every 12 months and treat HiPo status as a current view, not a permanent badge. People change roles, priorities and circumstances, and a list that never changes loses credibility fast.

Which tools help identify high potential employees?

The tools that help identify high potential employees are the 9-box grid, talent reviews, 360-degree feedback, skills and behavioral assessments, stretch assignments and HR performance data. No single tool is enough.

Each one covers a blind spot in the others, so most teams combine three or four.

Tool

What it shows

Watch out for

9-box grid

Performance against potential on one view

Potential ratings based on opinion alone

Talent review and calibration

A shared, cross-team view of who is ready

Loudest manager wins the debate

360-degree feedback

How peers, reports and managers see influence and behavior

Popularity mistaken for leadership

Skills and behavioral assessments

Learning agility, reasoning, judgment, personality on the same scale for everyone

Using tests that do not match the target role

Stretch assignments

Real behavior in a bigger role

Only giving stretch work to people already favored

Performance and HRIS data

Results, tenure, mobility history, flight risk

Rewarding past results only

A 360-degree feedback assessment is often the cheapest addition for teams that today rely only on manager opinion, because it brings in the people who see the employee every day.

How do skills assessments help identify high potential employees?

Skills assessments help identify high potential employees by measuring learning agility, reasoning, judgment and behavior on the same scale for every person, so potential is judged on evidence rather than visibility. Assessment scores give the talent review a fair starting point and show where manager views and data disagree.

A good HiPo assessment mix covers the capabilities you defined in step 1. Common building blocks:

  • Cognitive and critical thinking tests for how fast someone reasons through new, complex problems. Testlify's cognitive tests and critical thinking test are typical picks.
  • Situational judgment tests for decisions in realistic work scenarios.
  • Personality and emotional intelligence tests for work style and how someone handles people, such as the emotional intelligence test.
  • Role-specific skills tests to confirm the technical floor for the next role.

If you are setting one up for the first time, our glossary entry on HiPo assessment explains the term and how organizations use it.

Testlify's test library has 3,500+ tests covering cognitive ability, situational judgment, personality and role skills, and reports break each score down by skill with AI insights. Teams can weight each skill to match the role and benchmark people against the wider pool, which makes it easier to compare nominees from different departments.

Across the teams we work with, the useful moment is rarely the top score; it is the quiet employee whose results outrank the people managers nominated first.

How do you spot high potential candidates when hiring?

Spotting high potential candidates when hiring uses the same evidence as internal identification: a role-specific skills test to confirm the floor, plus a cognitive or situational judgment test to show learning speed and judgment. Send the assessment before the first recruiter call, so every applicant is compared on the same scale.

A few practical rules from internal HiPo work carry over to hiring:

  • Set pass thresholds before you see results: Deciding the bar after reading scores invites bias toward candidates you already like.
  • Use 2 to 3 assessments, not 6: One role test plus one or two tests of reasoning or judgment gives enough signal without exhausting candidates.
  • Adjust the order for senior roles: For director-level hires, a short intro call before the assessment keeps passive candidates engaged.
  • Use scores to shape the interview: If a candidate scored lower on one skill, probe it in a structured interview instead of treating the number as a verdict.
  • Close the loop: Compare assessment scores with 90-day and 12-month reviews, then adjust thresholds for the next intake.

Using the same assessment for new hires and internal nominees has a side benefit: HR can compare an external finalist with an internal candidate on the same report. Our page on internal mobility shows how teams use Testlify to fill roles from inside first.

What mistakes lead teams to pick the wrong high potential employees?

Teams pick the wrong high potential employees when the process rewards the wrong signals and skips the checks that keep it fair. Five mistakes show up most often, and each one narrows the pipeline to people who already look like current leaders:

  1. Equating results with potential: A top seller is not automatically a future sales leader. Check the capabilities for the next role, not the current one.
  2. Rewarding visibility: SHRM's 2026 look at the 9-box warns that managers often read confidence and self-promotion as potential, which leaves quieter strong performers out. Define potential before the session and test assumptions with data.
  3. One manager, one vote: A single manager's view is shaped by their own team and style. Calibration across teams catches outliers.
  4. Permanent labels: Someone tagged as a HiPo five years ago may no longer fit; someone missed then may fit now.
  5. Labels without development: Naming people without giving them stretch work or coaching raises expectations and then disappoints them.
Key takeaway: The aim is not a perfect list but a fair, repeatable one. A clear definition, the same evidence for every nominee and a cross-team review remove most of the bias that makes HiPo programs lose trust.

What should you do after you identify high potential employees?

After you identify high potential employees, give each one a development plan tied to a target role, a sponsor at least one level up, regular stretch work and an honest conversation about their path. Identification without development is the fastest way to lose the people you just found.

DDI's 2025 forecast shows why: high potential talent is 3.7 times more likely to leave in the next year if their manager does not regularly provide growth and development, and 4.8 times more likely to leave without a sense of purpose in their role. Not advancing at an acceptable rate makes them 3.1 times more likely to leave.

Internal moves are part of the answer, but most organizations are not set up for them. The LinkedIn Workplace Learning Report 2024 found that only 33% of employers have internal mobility programs and only 1 in 5 employees feels strongly confident they can make an internal move.

A simple plan for the first year:

  • Development plan: 2 to 3 capability gaps from the assessment report, each with a learning action and a stretch task.
  • Sponsor: a senior leader who meets them quarterly and argues for their next move.
  • Visible path: the target role and a realistic timeline of 2 to 5 years.
  • Check-ins: a 6-month review of progress against the capabilities, and a re-assessment at 12 months.

Final thoughts

Learning how to identify high potential employees is less about finding a perfect test and more about building a fair process: define potential for the roles you need, agree on evidence first, combine manager input with assessments and stretch work, then calibrate across teams. The same evidence-first approach works for spotting high potential candidates during hiring.

Start small. Pick one critical role, define 4 to 6 capabilities, and assess the people who could fill it in 3 years.

Ready to find your next leaders: Book a demo and we will walk you through building a leadership potential assessment for your team. Or start a 7-day free trial, no credit card needed.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Arushi Shah
Arushi Shah

People and Talent Partner

Arushi Shah runs day-to-day talent acquisition and candidate experience at Testlify. She writes on interviewing, structured hiring, and giving candidates a fair, fast process.

LinkedIn

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.