How to increase diversity in hiring: why hiring assessments matter
Why hiring assessments matter in a diverse workplace, and 7 steps to increase diversity in hiring with fair, accessible, job-related tests.

To learn how to increase diversity in hiring, start with how candidates are judged. Widen who can apply, then assess every applicant on the same job-related evidence: skills-based requirements, inclusive job ads, wider sourcing, job-relevant assessments, accessible test settings, structured interviews and a pass-rate check by group at every stage. That is the importance of hiring assessments in a diverse workplace: they replace pedigree and gut feel with proof of skill.
TL;DR
- Increase diversity in hiring by widening the pool with skills-based requirements and judging every candidate on the same job-related evidence.
- Hiring assessments matter because they score what people can do, not where they studied or who they know. LinkedIn estimates a skills-based approach makes US talent pools 15.9 times larger.
- Use job-specific tests, work samples and structured interviews first. Unstructured interviews and vague culture-fit screens let bias in most easily.
- Make every assessment accessible: screen reader support, extra time and other accommodations on request, and clear notice of how candidates are scored.
- Check pass rates by group at each stage. A group passing at under 80% of the top group's rate is a flag to review that stage.
- In 2026, NYC Local Law 144 and the EU AI Act still expect audits, notice and human review when AI scores candidates.

Why are hiring assessments important in a diverse workplace?
Hiring assessments are important in a diverse workplace because they judge every applicant on the same job-related tasks, so people without the usual degree, employer or network can still prove they can do the work. Resumes reward pedigree. A well-built assessment rewards skill, and that alone widens who gets through.
The size of that effect is large. LinkedIn's Economic Graph team reported in March 2025 that a skills-based approach expands the talent pool for a typical job 6.1 times globally and 15.9 times in the United States. The same research found that hiring on skills for AI roles could raise the share of women in the pool by up to 24%, and that workers without a bachelor's degree gain more from a skills-based model than degree holders.
Diversity is also about who can get through the door at all. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that 22.8% of people with a disability were employed in 2025, against 65.2% of people without one. Accessible, skills-first assessments are one of the few hiring changes that directly widen access for that group.
Three more reasons diversity hiring assessments earn their place:
- Consistency: Every candidate answers the same questions under the same scoring rules, so a strong answer counts the same whoever gives it.
- Evidence: Scores give the hiring team a record of why someone moved forward, which matters when a decision is questioned.
- Scale: One assessment can screen hundreds of applicants fairly, where manual resume review gets faster and less careful as volume rises.
Hiring assessments are not only a diversity tool. For how they improve the hiring decision itself, see our guide to recruiting assessments.
Where does bias enter the hiring process?
Bias enters the hiring process at every stage where people judge candidates on signals that are not the job: the requirements in the ad, where you source, how resumes are screened, how interviews run and how the final call is made. Each stage needs its own fix, and assessments cover the screening and selection stages.
Hiring stage | Where bias creeps in | Fix |
|---|---|---|
Job requirements | Degree or years-of-experience filters the job does not need | List the skills the job needs and test for them |
Job ad | Coded language, long wish lists | Plain language, must-have skills only |
Sourcing | Same schools, same referral networks | New channels, returners, community partners |
Resume screen | Names, schools, gaps and employer brands | Skills assessment before or instead of the resume screen |
Interview | Affinity bias, first impressions, different questions per candidate | Structured interviews with scorecards |
Final decision | Gut feel, "culture fit", one loud voice | Score-based debrief, diverse panel, documented reasons |
The common types of hiring bias, such as affinity bias, the halo effect, and confirmation bias, do most damage where there is no structure. Structure is what an assessment adds.
How to increase diversity in hiring without lowering the bar?
Increasing diversity in hiring without lowering the bar means keeping the bar on job skills and removing the hurdles that are not about the job. These seven steps work in order: the first three widen the pool, the next three judge it fairly, and the last one checks that the process really is fair.
- Set skills-based requirements: Write down the 5 to 8 skills the role needs on day one. Drop any degree or years-of-experience rule that does not map to one of them.
- Write inclusive job ads: Keep the must-haves short. Long wish lists put off qualified people who do not tick every box.
- Source beyond usual channels: Add schools, communities, returner programs and job boards you do not use today, and ask for referrals from every part of the team.
- Screen with job-related assessments: Give every applicant the same skills test before anyone reads a resume, or alongside a blind hiring resume review.
- Make every step accessible: Offer accommodations up front, support screen readers and offer extra time when a candidate asks for it.
- Run structured interviews: Use the same questions and scorecard for every candidate, and a panel that is not all one profile. Our guide to structured interviews shows how to set one up.
- Check pass rates by group: Compare how each group moves through each stage, and review any stage where one group falls behind.
Tools are the usual blocker. In SHRM's 2026 skills-first research, only 34% of organizations said they use skills-first strategies often or almost always, and 29% of HR professionals named a lack of tools for assessing skills as a top barrier. The same report found 67% agree that listing specific skills instead of only a degree brings in more qualified applicants.
Pro tip: Run the assessment before the resume screen. Once a reviewer has seen a name, school and last employer, the test result is read through that lens.
Which diversity hiring assessments work best?
Diversity hiring assessments work best when they mirror the real job: work samples, job-specific skills tests, situational judgment tests and structured interviews. Each one scores what the role needs. Assessments that measure things the job does not need, or that are scored loosely, are where differences between groups grow.
Assessment type | What it measures | Diversity upside | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
Work sample or job simulation | Doing a real task from the role | Very close to the job, easy to explain | Keep the time short and the task realistic |
Job-specific skills test | Knowledge and skills for the role | Same questions and scoring for all | Remove jargon not used on the job |
Situational judgment test | Choices in realistic work scenarios | Tests judgment without needing past titles | Scenarios should not assume one culture |
Structured interview | Answers to the same questions, scored on a scorecard | Cuts interviewer drift | Train interviewers on the scorecard |
General cognitive test | Reasoning and problem solving | Useful for learning-heavy roles | Can show larger score gaps between groups, so check pass rates closely |
Unstructured interview or culture-fit chat | Rapport and impressions | Little | Highest risk of affinity bias |
Situational judgment tests are a good addition for customer-facing and leadership roles, because they show how someone would handle the job without asking where they did it before.
Key takeaway: The closer an assessment is to the real work, the fairer and easier to defend it is. Mix two or three job-related formats instead of relying on one test.
How do you make assessments accessible to every candidate?
Making assessments accessible means a candidate's disability, language or device never decides the score. Accessible assessments work with screen readers and keyboards, offer extra time and other accommodations on request, explain the format in advance, and measure the job skill instead of the sense or motor skill used to answer.
Under the ADA guidance on algorithms and AI in hiring, employers must provide reasonable accommodations during hiring unless they cause undue hardship, and should tell applicants what technology is used and how they will be evaluated. The guidance gives examples, such as an online interview that does not work with a blind applicant's screen reader, or a computer test that requires sight for a job that does not.
A practical accessibility checklist for diversity hiring assessments:
- Tell candidates the format early: test length, question types, whether it is timed and how to ask for an accommodation.
- Offer accommodations without penalty: extra time, breaks, an alternative format or a live alternative, and never ask why.
- Check the tech: screen reader and keyboard support, captions on video questions, and a mobile-friendly test for candidates without a laptop.
- Remove language barriers: offer the test in the candidate's language when the job does not require a specific one, and keep instructions plain.
- Time only what the job times: a typing speed test should be timed, a policy writing task usually should not.
For the wider process around the test, see how to design a fair and inclusive hiring process.
How do you check whether an assessment is fair?
Checking whether an assessment is fair starts with comparing pass rates by group. The US Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures use the four-fifths rule: if one group passes at less than 80% of the rate of the group with the highest pass rate, that is generally treated as evidence of adverse impact to investigate.
Here is a worked example. Of 100 applicants in Group A, 60 pass the screening test, a 60% pass rate. Of 80 applicants in Group B, 36 pass, a 45% pass rate. The impact ratio is 45% divided by 60%, or 0.75. That is under 0.80, so the test needs a closer look.
A low ratio is a flag, not proof of bias. When a stage falls under the line, ask three questions:
- Is every question tied to a skill the job needs on day one?
- Is the format accessible, and were accommodations offered and used?
- Is there another assessment that measures the same skill with smaller differences between groups?
Run the check every quarter and on every high-volume role. Small groups give noisy numbers, so look at trends across several hiring rounds before you change a test. A pattern we have seen across hiring teams: the stage that hurts diversity most is often not the test at all, but an unstructured interview right after it.
What rules apply to diversity hiring and assessments in 2026?
The rules for diversity hiring and assessments in 2026 come from three places: anti-discrimination law, AI hiring laws and accessibility law. Title VII, the ADA and state laws still bar discrimination in hiring. New York City and the EU add audit, notice and oversight duties when AI or automated tools score candidates.
- New York City: Under Local Law 144, an automated employment decision tool needs a bias audit within one year of use, a public summary of the results, and notice to candidates at least 10 business days before it is used.
- European Union: The EU AI Act (Regulation (EU) 2024/1689) lists AI used to recruit or select people, including to filter applications and evaluate candidates, as high-risk. That brings duties on risk management, human oversight and record-keeping.
- US federal shift: Executive Order 14281, signed on April 23, 2025, tells federal agencies to deprioritize disparate-impact enforcement. It does not change Title VII itself, private lawsuits or state laws, so pass-rate checks are still worth running.
- Accessibility: The ADA applies to every hiring test, including online and AI-scored ones.
The public mood has cooled too. Pew Research Center found that 52% of US workers said focusing on diversity, equity and inclusion at work is mainly a good thing in October 2024, down from 56% in February 2023. Skills-based hiring sits well in that climate: it widens the pool by judging everyone on the same merit, without quotas. This is general information, not legal advice; check local law with counsel.
How do you measure diversity hiring progress?
Measuring diversity hiring progress means tracking the same few numbers at every stage of the funnel, split by group where candidates choose to share that data. Watch where people drop out, not only who gets hired, because the drop-off stage tells you what to fix.
- Applicant pool mix: who applies, by source and by role.
- Pass rate per stage: assessment, interview, offer, with the four-fifths check on each.
- Assessment completion rate: a low completion rate for one group often points to access or format problems.
- Offer acceptance rate: who says no, and why.
- Quality of hire: 6 and 12 month performance and retention, to confirm the new process picks people who succeed.
- Candidate feedback: a short survey after the assessment on fairness and clarity.
Keep demographic data voluntary, separate from the hiring decision and stored under your privacy policy. For broader workplace steps beyond hiring, see our guide to diversity in the workplace.
How does Testlify support diverse hiring?
Testlify supports diverse hiring by letting teams screen every applicant on the same role-specific skills test before anyone reads a resume. Hiring teams pick or build a test from the job description, candidates take it online in their language, and every answer is scored against the same criteria.
- Role-specific tests: 3,500+ tests across tech and non-tech roles, including situational judgment, language and job simulations, in the Testlify test library.
- Structure built in: an AI test builder that turns a job description into an assessment, weighted scoring and structured AI interviews that ask every candidate the same questions.
- Language access: assessments in 15+ languages, with candidate-side question translation. multilingual assessments
- Audited matching: Testlify's matching model completed a third-party bias audit under NYC Local Law 144 on June 16, 2023. NYC bias audit
- Fair scores you can trust: 20+ proctoring checks keep results honest, and benchmarking and question analytics show how each test performs across candidates.
Results sync to 100+ ATS and HRIS tools, so scores sit next to the candidate record for the debrief.
Ready to build a fairer shortlist?
Pick one high-volume role, put a skills test in front of the resume screen, and run the four-fifths check after the first hiring round. Browse the test library or start a 7-day free trial of Testlify, no credit card required.
Frequently asked questions (FAQs)
Related resources
View all
HR & recruitment
The role of hiring assessments in decision making

HR & recruitment
How to use psychometric tests to predict job performance

HR & recruitment
Using Big Five to identify candidates: a practical guide

HR & recruitment
Campus Hiring Trends 2026: 7 Shifts Redefining Early Talent Hiring

HR & recruitment
Why Big Five personality test is the best for hybrid work?

HR & recruitment
Big Five Personality Traits and Job Performance: A 2026 Hiring Guide
Get started.
Hire on proof, not resumes.
Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.