See what's new

Testlify
HR & recruitment
Last updated on: 6 November 202615 min read

Personality tests for employers: what they are and how to use them

What personality tests show employers, which types to use, where they fit in hiring, what the law allows and how to read results fairly.

Personality tests for employers: what they are and how to use them

Personality tests for employers are standardized questionnaires that show how a candidate tends to work: how they handle pressure, detail, other people and change. There are no right or wrong answers and no pass mark. Hiring teams use the results next to skills tests and structured interviews to judge fit for a specific role, never as the only reason to hire or reject someone.

TL;DR / Key takeaways
  • Personality tests for employers measure work style, not ability. Use them to judge how someone is likely to work, and use skills or cognitive tests to judge whether they can do the job.
  • Trait-based tests built on the Big Five are the safest default for hiring. DISC suits team and communication questions. MBTI was not built for selection and should not be used to screen candidates.
  • The best place for a personality test is before the interview, so the profile shapes the questions you ask instead of silently rejecting people.
  • Candidates can shade their answers. Forced-choice formats, consistency checks and interview follow-ups catch most of it.
  • In the US, a personality test is legal when it is job-related and applied to everyone the same way. Tests that probe mental health count as medical exams under the ADA and cannot be used before a job offer.
  • Read results as ranges and interview prompts, review them against hire outcomes after six to twelve months, and drop any trait that does not link to performance in that role.
Summarise this post with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

What are personality tests for employers?

Personality tests for employers are pre-hire questionnaires that score a candidate on stable traits such as conscientiousness, sociability, emotional steadiness and openness to new ways of working. Every candidate answers the same items, scored on the same scale, so profiles can be compared fairly across a pool.

They differ from other pre-hire tests in one important way. A cognitive ability test or a role skills test asks "can this person do the work?" A personality test asks "how is this person likely to go about the work?" The first has correct answers. The second describes preferences. That is why employers almost always pair the two instead of choosing one.

Personality tests are also different from job-seeker career quizzes. Free online quizzes that tell someone which career suits them are built for self-reflection. Tests built for employment use work-related statements, report on traits that matter in a job, and come with guidance on how to use the scores in a hiring decision.

personality tests
Build your dream team — Book a product demo

What do personality tests measure at work?

Personality tests measure the habits and preferences that shape everyday work: how someone plans, communicates, reacts to setbacks and works with others. Most employment tests report these as scores on a scale rather than as a single label, which keeps the picture more honest.

Trait

What it shows at work

Roles where it often matters

Conscientiousness

Planning, follow-through, care with detail

Almost every role, especially finance, operations, compliance

Extraversion

Energy from people, comfort speaking up

Sales, account management, recruiting

Agreeableness

Cooperation, tact, concern for others

Customer support, healthcare, team-based roles

Emotional stability

Steadiness under pressure, recovery from setbacks

Contact centers, incident response, leadership

Openness

Curiosity, comfort with new ideas and change

Product, design, research, fast-growing teams

The Big Five personality traits in the table are the model most employment tests are built on. A high or low score is not good or bad on its own. Low extraversion can be an asset in deep, solo analytical work, and very high agreeableness can make it hard to say no to a demanding customer. The job decides which end of the scale helps.

Pro tip: Before you choose a test, write down the two or three traits that really separate strong performers from weak ones in the role. Everything else in the report is background, not a scoring point.

What types of personality tests do employers use?

Employers mostly use four families of personality tests: trait-based tests built on the Big Five, behavioral style tests such as DISC, type-based tests such as the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI), and picture-based tests that ask candidates to react to images instead of statements.

  • Big Five (trait-based): Scores five traits on a scale: openness, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and emotional stability. Short, easy to read and the most widely used model for hiring decisions. Testlify's SMART personality test is built on it.
  • DISC (behavioral style): Places people on four styles: Dominance, Influence, Steadiness and Conscientiousness. Useful for questions about communication, team mix and how someone likes to be managed. See the DISC personality test.
  • MBTI (type-based): Sorts people into one of 16 types across four pairs: extraversion or introversion, sensing or intuition, thinking or feeling, judging or perceiving. It is popular for team workshops and self-awareness, but it was not designed for selection, and boxing candidates into types invites unfair decisions. Keep it for development, not screening.
  • Picture-based tests: Ask candidates to pick images that feel most like them. They work well across languages and for roles where long text questionnaires put people off. The PicOCEAN personality test maps image choices to Big Five traits.

Two neighbours often get grouped with these. Situational judgment tests present work scenarios and ask what the candidate would do, so they measure judgment rather than personality. Integrity tests look at honesty and rule-following. Projective methods are a different kind of personality assessment: candidates respond to open prompts such as ambiguous pictures or unfinished sentences, and a trained reviewer interprets the answers. They take longer to score, so employers rarely use them to screen large applicant pools.

Why do employers use personality tests?

Employers use personality tests to add a structured, comparable read on work style to a process that otherwise judges personality by gut feel in the first minutes of an interview. Interviewers form views on personality anyway. A test replaces an unstructured impression with the same questions and the same scoring for everyone.

The main reasons hiring teams give:

  • Better interviews: A profile tells the interviewer where to dig. If a role is full of ambiguity and a candidate scores low on comfort with change, that becomes a question, not a rejection.
  • Fit with the role, not the team: Good use matches a person's preferences to what the job demands each day, such as constant customer contact or long stretches of detail work. It does not mean hiring people who resemble the current team.
  • Consistency at volume: When hundreds of people apply, a short test gives every applicant the same chance to show how they work, before anyone sees a photo or a university name.
  • Quality of hire: Hiring teams are under pressure to show that hires work out. According to LinkedIn's Future of Recruiting report, 89% of talent acquisition professionals say measuring quality of hire will become more important, yet only 25% feel highly confident they can measure it today. Work style data captured at hire gives that measurement a starting point.

When should a personality test come in the hiring process?

A personality test works best after the resume or skills screen and before the first interview. At that point, results reach the interviewer in time to shape the conversation, and the test is not used as a blunt first cut that throws out good people for the wrong reasons.

Where personality tests for employers fit in the hiring process, from screening to offer

The placement depends on the role:

  • High-volume roles: Combine a short personality test with a skills test at the screening stage, so one invite does the first sift and candidates are not asked twice. Use the personality score to rank, not to reject on its own.
  • Professional and specialist roles: Send the test after the skills screen. The interviewer gets the profile the day before and prepares two or three follow-up questions from it.
  • Senior and leadership roles: Use the test at the shortlist stage to compare finalists whose experience is similar, and discuss the results openly with each candidate.

Keep the candidate's time in mind. A personality test of 10 to 20 minutes is normal. Stacking several long questionnaires before any human contact pushes strong applicants toward employers who ask less of them.

How should employers use personality tests step by step?

Employers should use personality tests as one planned step in a structured process, decided before the role opens rather than added after a bad hire. A simple sequence keeps the test fair, useful and defensible.

  1. Analyze the job: List the tasks, the working conditions and the two or three traits that link to success in this role. Keep this note: it is your record that the test is job-related.
  2. Pick a test built for employment: Choose a work-focused, trait-based test over a type-based or clinical one. Check that it reports on the traits from step 1.
  3. Decide its weight: Set how much the personality score counts next to skills, cognitive and interview scores before you see any results. Personality is usually a smaller share than skills.
  4. Run it the same way for everyone: Same test, same time limit, same instructions and the same accommodations process for all candidates in the job category.
  5. Turn results into interview questions: Pass each profile to the interviewer with suggested prompts, and score answers in a structured interview so the follow-up is fair too.
  6. Review outcomes: After six to twelve months, compare scores at hire with performance, early attrition and manager ratings. Keep the traits that link to success and drop the ones that do not.
Key takeaway: A personality test is only as good as the job analysis behind it. If you cannot say why a trait matters for this role, do not score it.

Are personality tests accurate, and can candidates fake them?

Personality tests are reasonably accurate at describing how someone sees their own work style, and candidates can shade their answers when they guess what the employer wants. Both points are true, and good test design and good process deal with them.

The main limits to plan for:

  • Self-report: Candidates describe themselves. Someone may call themselves a strong communicator because they talk well, even if they listen poorly.
  • Faking: A candidate for a sales job can guess that "I enjoy meeting new people" is the answer to give. Forced-choice items, where every option sounds equally positive, make this much harder. Consistency checks flag profiles that contradict themselves.
  • Context: People behave differently in different settings. A calm person at home may still struggle on a chaotic contact center floor.
  • Culture and language: Statements can read differently across cultures and in a second language. Offer the test in the candidate's language and prefer image-based items for multilingual pools.

The best defence is the interview. Treat a profile as a set of claims to test with real examples. Ask "Tell me about a time you had to act before you had all the facts" and a faked profile rarely survives the answer. For more on the trade-offs, see the pros and cons of personality tests in hiring.

Personality tests for employers are legal in the US and most other markets, as long as the test is related to the job, given to all candidates in the same way and does not screen out protected groups without a business reason. The details sit in a few federal laws.

The EEOC fact sheet on employment tests and selection procedures lists personality tests as a selection procedure covered by federal anti-discrimination law. The EEOC reports that a test can break the law even when it looks neutral, if it shuts out one group of candidates more than others. Three rules matter most:

  • Title VII: A neutral test that excludes people of a particular race, sex, religion or national origin at a higher rate is unlawful unless it is job-related and consistent with business necessity, and even then a less discriminatory alternative can win.
  • ADA: Psychological tests that assess mental health are medical examinations. An employer cannot require them, or ask disability-related questions, until after a conditional job offer. A workplace personality test must stay clear of items like "Do you often feel low for days at a time?"
  • Accommodations: Employers must adjust how a test is given for a candidate with a disability, such as extra time or a screen reader, unless that would cause undue hardship.
Legal checklist for personality tests for employers under Title VII and the ADA

When software scores or ranks candidates, local rules can add duties. New York City's Local Law 144, for example, requires a bias audit and candidate notice for automated employment decision tools. Testlify had a third-party NYC Local Law 144 bias audit of its matching model completed in June 2023. Outside the US, check local data protection rules before you store personality data, and tell candidates how long you keep it.

How do you read personality test results without labelling people?

Personality test results should be read as ranges and prompts for the interview, not as a verdict on whether someone can do the job. A score describes the conditions in which a person is likely to do their best work.

A few habits keep the reading fair:

  • Look at the traits you chose: Ignore the rest of the report for the hiring decision, however interesting it is.
  • Read ranges, not labels: Nobody is purely one type. A middle score usually means the person adapts to the situation.
  • Look for clashes, not perfect matches: The useful signal is a big gap between the profile and the daily reality of the job, which you then explore in the interview.
  • Never reject on the profile alone: Combine it with skills scores, interview evidence and references.

Getting this right pays off after the hire too. Gallup's State of the Global Workplace report found global employee engagement fell to 20%, and manager engagement dropped from 27% to 22% in a single year. A personality profile shared with the new manager gives them a head start on how that person likes to receive feedback and work with others. For a closer look at scoring, read how to interpret the results of personality tests.

What mistakes should employers avoid with personality tests?

The most common mistakes are using the wrong kind of test, using one test for every role and treating the score as a pass or fail. Each one makes the test less useful and the process less fair.

  • Using MBTI or a free online quiz to screen: These were not built for selection decisions.
  • One profile for every job: The traits that help a support agent differ from those that help a data engineer.
  • Hiring clones: Matching candidates to the current team's profile shrinks the range of people you hire.
  • Cut-off scores on personality alone: A hard cut on a trait score rejects people who would have done well.
  • Long, stacked tests: Several questionnaires before any human contact raises drop-off.
  • Never checking results: If you never compare scores with outcomes, you do not know whether the test helps.

How does Testlify help employers run personality tests?

Testlify helps employers run personality tests inside the same assessment as skills tests, so one candidate invite covers both work style and ability. Hiring teams pick from a library of 3,500+ tests that includes personality and culture tests such as Big Five based SMART, DISC and the picture-based PicOCEAN, then combine them with role-specific, cognitive and situational judgment tests.

  • One assessment, weighted scores: Set how much the personality section counts next to skills, and see a per-skill breakdown with AI candidate insights for each person.
  • Fair and secure delivery: Tests run in 15+ languages, with 20+ proctoring checks and anti-cheating and proctoring settings you control.
  • Fits your stack: Results sync to 100+ ATS and HRIS tools through Testlify integrations, including Workday, Greenhouse and Lever.

Ready to add a personality test to your hiring process?

Pick one open role, write down the two or three traits that matter, and add a personality test next to the skills test you already use. Browse the personality tests in the Testlify test library or start a 7-day free trial, no credit card required.

Frequently asked questions

Yashika Khandelwal
Yashika Khandelwal

Content Writer

Yashika Khandelwal is a Content Writer with 3+ years of experience creating research-backed content on hiring, talent assessment, and HR technology. She is a registered Organizational Psychologist and subject matter expert who combines behavioral science with practical recruitment insights to produce accurate, evidence-based content.

LinkedIn

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.