See what's new

Testlify
Back to HR Glossary
HR Glossary

Integrity Testing

Integrity testing measures how likely a candidate is to act honestly, follow rules and avoid theft or misconduct at work before you hire.

Summarise this term with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

Integrity testing is a pre-employment assessment that measures how likely a candidate is to act honestly, follow rules and avoid counterproductive behavior such as theft, lying, absenteeism or policy breaches at work. An integrity test asks direct questions about honesty, scenario questions or personality items, and gives employers a risk signal to weigh with skills tests, interviews and checks.

Image showing the meaning of Integrity Testing

Employers also call it an honesty test or a counterproductive behavior test. Most use it at the hiring stage, and some use it again for promotions into roles of trust.

Why does integrity testing matter for enterprise HR?

Integrity testing matters because skills tests show what a candidate can do, not whether they will do it honestly. Dishonesty in hiring is common: in Checkr's Hiring Hoax survey of 3,000 US hiring managers (September 2025), 60% said they had caught a candidate misrepresenting their experience or qualifications, and another 13% suspected it but could not prove it.

For TA leaders hiring at volume, an integrity test adds four things:

  • Lower risk in roles of trust: Cash handling, inventory, customer data, financial controls and safety-sensitive work are where one bad hire costs the most.
  • A fairer screen than many alternatives: The US Office of Personnel Management notes that integrity tests show few average score differences by sex, race or ethnicity, so they can offset the adverse impact of a cognitive test.
  • Low cost at scale: OPM also notes that buying an existing test costs less than building one, and that it needs no skilled administrator, which suits large applicant pools.
  • Fewer early exits: Hiring people who are dependable and follow rules cuts disciplinary cases and early turnover, so recruiters refill fewer seats.

What are the types of integrity tests?

Integrity tests come in two main types, overt and personality-based (also called covert), and many employers add situational judgment items. Most modern tests mix all three so that one answer style cannot carry the score.

Type

What it measures

Example item

Strength

Watch out for

Overt (clear-purpose)

Attitudes toward theft, lying and rule-breaking, and admitted past behavior

"Is it ever acceptable to take small items from an employer?"

Direct and easy to explain to candidates

Easier to fake, because the "right" answer is obvious

Personality-based (covert)

Traits linked to reliable conduct: conscientiousness, dependability, emotional stability, rule-following

"I consider myself a risk-taker." (agree or disagree)

Harder to game, feels like a normal personality test

Items can look unrelated to the job, so explain the purpose

Situational judgment

How a candidate handles an ethical gray area at work

"A customer hands you too much change. What do you do?"

Close to real job decisions

Needs scenarios that fit the role and culture

Blended

All of the above, with consistency checks across items

Same theme asked in different ways

Flags inconsistent or overly perfect answers

Longer test, so keep it to about 15 to 20 minutes

Whatever the format, an integrity test usually reports on the same attributes: honesty, trustworthiness, dependability, rule and policy adherence, work ethic and ethical decision-making.

How do you run an integrity test in hiring?

An integrity test works best as a planned step in the hiring process, not a last-minute filter. These steps bring together what works for most TA teams:

  1. Define the integrity attributes for the role: List the behaviors that matter, such as handling cash, protecting client data or following safety rules, and tie them to your company values.
  2. Pick the test type: Choose overt, personality-based, situational or blended items based on the role's risk and how much faking you expect.
  3. Check the law where you hire: Confirm state and country rules before launch, and review the questions with counsel (see the comparison below).
  4. Place it after the first screen: Run the integrity test after resume or skills screening and before final interviews, so you test a manageable group and still have time to follow up.
  5. Tell candidates what it is for: Explain the purpose, how results are used and that answers stay confidential. Candidates who understand the test answer more candidly.
  6. Read results with other data: Combine the score with skills tests, structured interviews, reference checks and background checks. Probe low or inconsistent scores in the interview rather than rejecting on the score alone.
  7. Review outcomes every year: Track pass rates by group to spot adverse impact, and compare scores with later performance and turnover.
Key takeaway: The test is one input. The decision still comes from a structured process with human review.

How is an integrity test different from a background check?

An integrity test predicts how a person is likely to behave, while a background check verifies what a person has already done. A polygraph is a third, separate tool, and its use in hiring is largely banned in the US.

Integrity test

Background check

Polygraph

What it looks at

Attitudes and traits linked to honest, reliable conduct

Criminal records, past employment, education, credit where permitted

Body responses while answering questions

Time frame

Likely future behavior

Documented past

Answers given during the test

When used

After the first screen, before final interviews

Usually after a conditional offer

Rarely; only in narrow exempt cases

US federal status

Allowed; written honesty tests are outside the polygraph law

Allowed, with consent and adverse action rules

Banned for most private employers under the Employee Polygraph Protection Act

State limits

Massachusetts treats written honesty tests as lie detector tests

Ban-the-box and credit check limits in many states

Varies

The federal rule is explicit: the EPPA regulations at 29 CFR 801.2 leave written or oral honesty and "paper and pencil" tests out of the definition of a lie detector. Massachusetts is the main exception. Its lie detector statute (M.G.L. c. 149, s. 19B) covers written examinations used to judge honesty and requires a notice on job applications, and law firms reported a wave of class actions under it in 2024 and 2025. Check this before you test candidates in that state.

What are the best practices for integrity testing?

Integrity testing best practices focus on fairness, faking and candidate trust:

  • Use it as one input, never the only one: A single score cannot capture character, and multi-method hiring is easier to defend.
  • Match the test to role risk: Reserve the deepest checks for roles with cash, data, safety or financial access, where the payoff is highest.
  • Design against faking: Blend item types, use consistency and candidness checks, and proctor online tests. Checkr's 2025 survey found 59% of managers had suspected a candidate of using AI to misrepresent themselves.
  • Keep every item job-related: Skip questions on health, religion or private life. The EEOC guidance on employment tests expects tests to be job-related and to avoid screening out protected groups.
  • Offer accommodations: Give extra time or another format to candidates with a disability that affects test-taking.
  • Protect the data: Limit who sees scores, set a retention period and follow GDPR or local privacy law.
Pro tip: Pair an integrity test with a cognitive ability test or a role skills test. Together they show both whether a candidate can do the job and how they are likely to do it.

Integrity testing fits naturally into skills-based hiring. The Testlify integrity test is a 15-minute situational judgment test that covers ethical decision-making, trustworthiness, honesty, policy adherence and work ethic, and it can run alongside role skills tests from a library of 3,500+ tests with 20+ proctoring checks. For interview follow-ups, see how to assess the ethical judgment of candidates.

Frequently asked questions

Integrity tests are legal for most US employers, because federal law excludes written honesty tests from its polygraph ban. Massachusetts is the main exception, as its lie detector statute covers written honesty tests. Employers everywhere must keep the test job-related and check it for adverse impact.

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.