See what's new

Testlify
HR & recruitment
Last updated on: 19 November 202616 min read

Succession planning process: 7 steps for HR teams in 2027

A 7-step succession planning process for HR teams: critical roles, fair assessment, successor slates, development plans and the metrics.

Succession planning process: 7 steps for HR teams in 2027

The succession planning process is how an organization finds the roles it cannot afford to leave empty, picks and tests the people who could step into them, and develops those people until they are ready. Done well, a leader can leave on short notice and the business keeps moving, because a prepared successor and a written handover are already in place.

TL;DR:

  • The succession planning process has 7 steps: set goals and owners, identify critical roles, build success profiles, assess candidates, build successor slates, develop successors, then hand over and review.
  • Most organizations still have no formal plan. SHRM found only 22% of HR leaders reported one in 2025, and just 16% of smaller organizations.
  • Plan for roles, not people. Most companies have about 20 to 50 positions that really move strategy; start there.
  • Name 2 to 3 successors per critical role with a readiness level (ready now, 1 to 2 years, 3+ years) instead of one heir.
  • Judge potential and readiness separately from current performance, using the same structured assessment for every candidate.
  • Review the plan every 6 months and track bench strength, internal fill rate and successor retention.
Summarise this post with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

What is the succession planning process?

The succession planning process is a repeatable cycle for keeping critical roles covered: you decide which roles matter most, define what success in them will need, assess internal candidates against that profile, and close their gaps with planned development. It covers leaders and also key specialists, from a plant manager to a lead data engineer.

Succession planning is often confused with replacement planning. Replacement planning only names who would fill a seat tomorrow. Succession planning prepares people for what the role will need in two or three years, and builds a pool deep enough to survive a surprise exit. For the short definition, see the succession planning glossary entry.

Aspect

Replacement planning

Succession planning

Question it answers

Who sits in this seat if the holder leaves tomorrow?

Who will be ready to lead this role as it changes?

Time horizon

Now

1 to 5 years

Candidates

One named backup

A slate of 2 to 3 people plus a wider talent pool

Basis

Current job and seniority

Future success profile, potential and readiness

Development

Little or none

Individual development plans with stretch work

Review

When someone resigns

Every 6 months and after any big change

Build your dream team — Book a product demo

Why does the succession planning process matter?

The succession planning process matters because leadership exits are certain and their timing is not. Without a plan, a resignation becomes an expensive external search, institutional knowledge walks out, and teams stall while the role sits empty. Yet most organizations still run without one.

  • Few formal plans: SHRM found that in 2025 just 22% of HR leaders said their organization had a formal succession plan. The gap is widest in smaller firms: 16% of smaller organizations had one, against 44% of extra-large ones.
  • Experience is concentrated: According to the US Bureau of Labor Statistics, the BLS Employee Tenure release put median tenure at 9.6 years for workers aged 55 to 64 in January 2026, against 3.0 years for ages 25 to 34. Your longest-serving people hold the most knowledge and are closest to leaving.
  • Priority is rising: According to the same SHRM research, 42% of talent management executives named creating a succession strategy as a top focus area for 2026.

A clear process also keeps your best people. When high performers can see a real path to the next role, they have one less reason to take a recruiter's call.

Who owns the succession planning process?

The succession planning process is owned by HR and run with senior leaders. HR designs the process and keeps the data; the CEO and executive team decide on successors for the top roles; the board oversees CEO succession; line managers nominate and develop their people. Employees own their own development plan.

Role

What they own in the process

Board of directors

CEO and C-suite succession, emergency cover for the CEO

CEO and executive team

Which roles are critical, final successor decisions, calibration

CHRO or Head of Talent

Process design, timeline, budget, reporting

HR business partners

Talent reviews with each function, keeping the plan current

Line managers

Nominating candidates, giving stretch work, coaching

L&D team

Development programs, mentoring, coaching

Successors

Their individual development plan and honest career goals

7 steps of the succession planning process

The succession planning process follows 7 steps: set goals and owners, identify critical roles, build success profiles, assess candidates, build successor slates, develop successors, and plan the handover with a regular review. Each step feeds the next, and step 7 loops back to step 2 whenever strategy or people change.

The succession planning process in 7 steps, from goals to handover and review

1. Set goals, owners and a timeline

Start by writing down what the plan must achieve: cover every critical role, cut external hiring for senior roles, or keep knowledge when a founder steps back. Name the owners from the table above, agree a budget for development, and set a review rhythm. A one-page succession policy that covers planned exits and sudden vacancies saves arguments later.

2. Identify critical roles

Critical roles are the positions that would hurt the business most if they sat empty. Look at revenue impact, how hard the role is to hire for, how unique the knowledge is, and how close the current holder is to retirement or a move. SHRM's guidance is that most firms have roughly 20 to 50 positions that really move strategy.

Do not stop at the executive team: a sole payroll specialist or the only engineer who knows a legacy system can be just as critical. For a fuller method, read how to identify key positions for succession planning.

3. Build a success profile for each role

A success profile lists what the next holder of the role will need, not just what today's holder does. Include the hard skills, leadership behaviors, experience (for example, managing managers or owning a budget) and the traits the role needs as the business changes. Ask department heads where the role is going: a sales director role in 2028 may need data and AI skills that the current director never used.

4. Assess performance, potential and readiness

Assess every candidate on three separate things: current performance, potential to grow, and readiness for this specific role. Use more than one source of evidence: performance reviews, 360 feedback, structured skills and leadership assessments, and career interest. Tell candidates the criteria. The next section explains how to keep this step fair.

5. Build successor slates and talent pools

For each critical role, name 2 to 3 successors with a readiness level instead of one heir apparent. One name fails the day that person resigns or turns the role down. Add an emergency cover name who could hold the role for a few months.

Behind the slates, keep a wider talent pool of high potentials from different teams, regions and backgrounds, so the next slate is never built from the same few people.

6. Develop successors with individual plans

Turn each candidate's gaps against the success profile into an individual development plan with dates and evidence of progress. Mix stretch assignments, cross-functional projects, mentoring from senior leaders and formal training.

Development should test readiness, not just teach: let a successor lead a team for six months or own the next budget cycle. Our guide on how to create a leadership development plan covers the format.

Development gap

Action

Evidence of progress

Has never managed managers

Lead two teams during a six-month assignment

Team results and upward feedback

No budget ownership

Own the department's next planning cycle

Approved budget, monthly variance reviews

Little exposure to senior leaders

Present a strategic project to the executive team

Executive feedback, project outcome

Narrow functional view

Join a cross-functional project or job rotation

Stakeholder feedback, delivered project

7. Plan the handover and review the plan

When a move happens, plan the handover as carefully as the selection. Set a transition period where the outgoing and incoming leaders overlap, use shadowing and joint meetings with key clients and teams, and write down the decisions, contacts and unwritten rules that live in one person's head. Support the new leader for 6 to 12 months after the move.

Then review the whole plan every 6 months, and again after a reorganization, an acquisition or a key resignation. Gather feedback from successors, managers and leaders who went through a handover, update readiness levels, and add roles that the new strategy has made critical.

Pro tip: Run your first cycle on 5 to 10 critical roles in one business unit. A small pilot shows where the data is thin and where managers disagree before you roll the process out company wide.

How do you assess succession candidates fairly?

Succession candidates are assessed fairly when every person for a role is measured against the same success profile, with the same evidence, and when performance and potential are scored separately. A manager's opinion alone favors people who look and work like the manager, so combine it with structured assessments and calibration across leaders.

9-box grid for succession planning with the action for each group

The 9-box matrix plots current performance against potential and is a good starting point for talent reviews. It is a discussion tool, not the plan itself: a top performer in a specialist role may have no wish or aptitude to lead. Pair it with a readiness level for the specific role.

Readiness level

What it means

What to do

Ready now

Could take the role with normal onboarding

Name as primary successor, keep engaged

Ready in 1 to 2 years

One or two clear gaps with a realistic plan to close them

Targeted stretch work and mentoring

Ready in 3+ years

Promising, but needs several key experiences

Keep in the talent pool, broad development

Emergency cover

Could hold the role for a few months

Brief them on the role, keep notes current

To make the evidence objective, use the same assessments for every candidate on a slate:

  • Leadership and judgment: A leadership potential test or a leadership and people management test shows how candidates reason about people decisions.
  • Thinking skills: Problem-solving, critical thinking and situational judgment tests show how they handle new, messy problems.
  • Behavior and fit: Emotional intelligence and personality tests add context on working style, not a pass mark.
  • Peer view: 360 feedback from peers and direct reports catches what a manager does not see.

For more on running a talent review, see how to assess the current talent pool for succession planning and the glossary entry on high-potential employees.

How should you communicate a succession plan?

A succession plan should be communicated openly at the level of process and criteria, and privately at the level of names. Tell every employee how the process works, what the criteria for advancement are and how to raise their hand. Tell each successor where they stand and what they need to develop, without promising the job.

  • Explain the process: Share the purpose, the steps and the criteria, so promotions read as merit, not favoritism.
  • Hold career conversations: Ask people about their ambitions every review cycle. Some top performers do not want to lead, and you need to know that before you build a slate around them.
  • Avoid crown princes: Never promise a role. Use language such as "you are one of the people we are developing for this role".
  • Keep the door open: Give people not on a slate a clear path to join the talent pool, such as an assessment or a project.

How do you measure the succession planning process?

The succession planning process is measured with a few outcome numbers reviewed every 6 months: bench strength, internal fill rate, readiness movement, successor retention, slate diversity and how new leaders perform after the move. Process counts, such as the number of plans written, say little on their own.

Metric

How to calculate it

Warning sign

Bench strength

Critical roles with at least one ready-now successor / all critical roles

Below half of critical roles covered

Internal fill rate

Critical roles filled internally / critical roles filled

Most senior roles still hired from outside

Readiness movement

Successors who moved up a readiness level in 12 months

Same people stuck at "ready in 1 to 2 years"

Successor retention

Named successors still employed after 12 months

Successors leaving faster than other staff

Slate diversity

Mix of teams, regions, genders and backgrounds on slates

Slates drawn from one team or profile

Success after move

New leaders meeting goals 12 months after promotion

Promotions that fail or reverse

One more check is worth running: watch how often people rated "ready now" keep getting passed over. If it happens again and again, the assessments or the decisions need fixing. Our guide to succession planning metrics goes deeper.

How is the succession planning process changing?

The succession planning process is moving from a secret list of executive heirs to a skills-based, company-wide pipeline. Remote and hybrid teams, new digital skills, a workforce spanning several generations and better HR data all change who counts as a successor and how readiness is judged.

  • Beyond the top team: Critical roles now include specialists and middle managers, not only the C-suite. Every level of the hierarchy can hold a single point of failure.
  • Skills over titles: Success profiles now add data literacy, AI fluency and the ability to lead teams people rarely see in person. Many future roles do not exist yet, so look for people who learn fast.
  • Remote leaders: Successors for distributed teams need proof they can lead across time zones and screens, so test them with remote projects before the move.
  • Several generations: Balance long experience with newer skills. Reverse mentoring, where junior staff teach new tools, works in both directions.
  • Continuous feedback: Regular check-ins replace the annual review as the main source of readiness data, and employees share their own career goals.
  • Data and AI: HR systems can map skills, track development and flag readiness gaps. Keep a person in charge of every decision and check the data for bias.

The manager bench is under strain too. Gallup's State of the Global Workplace release found manager engagement fell from 27% to 22% in 2025, down nine points since 2022. Disengaged managers make weak mentors and are flight risks themselves, so successor plans for manager roles need more depth, not less.

What mistakes break the succession planning process?

The succession planning process usually breaks for the same few reasons: treating performance as potential, naming successors but never developing them, planning only for executives, betting on one heir, and letting the plan go stale. Each one is avoidable with clear criteria and a fixed review date.

  • Performance taken as potential: The best individual contributor is not always the best manager. Assess potential and readiness on their own.
  • Names without development: A list of successors with no development plan is only a replacement chart. Fund the plans.
  • Executives only: Critical specialist roles cause just as much damage when they sit empty.
  • One heir apparent: A single name fails if that person leaves, and it discourages everyone else.
  • Stale plans: A plan last updated two reorganizations ago is worse than none, because it gives false comfort.
  • Resistance to change: People used to promotions by tenure may push back. Explain the benefits and the criteria early.
  • Bias and closed doors: Slates built from the leader's own circle shrink the pool. See how to promote diversity in leadership roles to widen it.
  • Internal or external only: Grow most successors inside, but hire from outside when a role needs skills nobody internal has yet.
Key takeaway: A succession plan works when it is about roles, evidence and development, and when it is reviewed on a fixed date. A list of names in a drawer is not a plan.

What should a succession plan template include?

A succession plan template should hold one row per critical role, with the current holder, the risk of the role becoming vacant, 2 to 3 successors with their readiness level, the main development gaps and actions, an emergency cover name and the next review date. Keep it in one shared file that HR updates after every talent review.

Critical role

Current holder and exit risk

Successors and readiness

Key gaps

Development actions

Emergency cover

Next review

Head of Customer Support

A. Rao, high (retiring in 18 months)

J. Kim (ready now); L. Ortiz (1 to 2 years)

Budget ownership; vendor contracts

Own 2027 budget; shadow vendor reviews

Support Ops Manager

March 2027

Lead Data Engineer

M. Chen, medium

P. Shah (1 to 2 years); R. Diaz (3+ years)

Architecture decisions; leading people

Lead migration project; mentoring

External contractor list

March 2027

To see how other companies run the process, read our roundup of succession planning case studies.

How does Testlify support the succession planning process?

Testlify supports the succession planning process at the assessment step, where most plans are weakest. HR teams can give every internal candidate for a role the same set of skills, leadership, cognitive and personality tests, then compare results side by side instead of relying on opinions.

  • Tests for leadership roles: The library holds 3,500+ tests, including leadership, situational judgment, cognitive ability and personality tests such as Big Five and DISC.
  • Evidence per skill: Reports show a per-skill breakdown, AI-written strengths and gaps, and benchmarks, so you can see each candidate's readiness gaps against the success profile.
  • Peer view: 360 feedback and custom tests built from your own success profile.
  • Fair and global: The same questions and scoring for every candidate, in 15+ languages, with 20+ proctoring checks when an assessment counts.

Ready to back your succession plan with evidence?

Pick one critical role, build its success profile, and assess every candidate on the same tests. Browse leadership and cognitive tests in the Testlify test library, start a 7-day free trial with no credit card, or book a demo to see how internal assessments fit your talent reviews.

Frequently asked questions (FAQs)

Arushi Shah
Arushi Shah

People and Talent Partner

Arushi Shah runs day-to-day talent acquisition and candidate experience at Testlify. She writes on interviewing, structured hiring, and giving candidates a fair, fast process.

LinkedIn

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.