See what's new

Testlify
Interview questions
Last updated on: 9 November 202617 min read

50 fundraising manager interview questions to ask in 2026

Fundraising manager interview questions by skill area, with answer guides, red flags and a 1 to 5 rubric to compare candidates fairly.

50 fundraising manager interview questions to ask in 2026

Fundraising manager interview questions test whether a candidate can plan a fundraising strategy, build and keep a donor pipeline, close major gifts, use data to decide where effort goes, and lead a team and a board toward a revenue goal. The 50 questions below are grouped by skill area, so you can build an interview kit for any fundraising role, from an annual giving manager to a director of development.

TL;DR:

  • Good fundraising manager interview questions cover eight skill areas: strategy, donor pipeline and stewardship, major and planned gifts, data and CRM, events and digital, grants and partners, leadership, and ethics.
  • Retention matters more than ever. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project found overall donor retention was 43.3% in 2025, while donor counts fell 3.6% even as dollars rose 5.0%.
  • The strongest signal is a specific, measured example: the size of the portfolio, the gift, the timeline and what the candidate did when a donor said no.
  • Ask every candidate the same questions and score each answer from 1 to 5 against anchors you write before the interview.
  • Vague "relationship building" with no numbers, no view of the board's role and no ethics boundaries are the most common red flags.
  • Put a fundraising skills test and a short writing task before the panel, so interview time goes on judgment, not basics.
Summarise this post with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

What does a fundraising manager do, and what should interviews test?

A fundraising manager plans and runs the programs that bring money into a nonprofit, school, hospital foundation or cause: setting the strategy, finding and meeting donors, applying for grants, running events and campaigns, and managing the team that delivers the goal. Interviews should test each of those duties, plus the judgment and ethics the role depends on.

The US Bureau of Labor Statistics lists those same duties for fundraising managers, puts their median pay at $125,470 (May 2025) and projects 5% job growth from 2025 to 2035. Most roles ask for a bachelor's degree and five or more years of related experience, so you are usually interviewing people with a track record you can probe.

Eight skill areas fundraising manager interview questions should test, with one example question for each

The eight skill areas used in this guide:

  1. Strategy and planning: Annual plans, revenue mix, goals and budgets.
  2. Donor pipeline and stewardship: Finding, cultivating, thanking and keeping donors.
  3. Major and planned gifts: Sizing and making the ask, legacy giving.
  4. Data, CRM and reporting: Donor records, segmentation, metrics and forecasts.
  5. Events, campaigns and digital: Galas, appeals, peer-to-peer and online giving.
  6. Grants and corporate partners: Foundation proposals, reporting and sponsorships.
  7. Leadership, board and team: Managing fundraisers, volunteers and board members.
  8. Ethics and compliance: Gift acceptance, donor privacy and restricted funds.
Build your dream team — Book a product demo

Which fundraising interview questions fit each role?

Fundraising titles cover very different jobs, so pick questions by what the person will do most. A major gift officer spends most of the week with donors; a development director spends more of it on strategy, the board and the team. Use the table to choose the sections to weight most heavily.

Role

Weight most

Lighter touch

Annual giving or individual giving manager

Pipeline and stewardship, data and CRM, digital

Grants

Major gift officer

Major and planned gifts, pipeline, ethics

Events

Director of development or fundraising manager

Strategy, leadership and board, data, ethics

None, cover all eight

Grants manager

Grants and partners, writing task, reporting

Events

Events and campaigns manager

Events and digital, budgets, data

Planned gifts

For a grants-heavy role, add the [grant writing interview](/interviews/grant-writing-discussion/) to the process. For an events-heavy role, the [event planner interview questions](/event-planner-interview-questions-to-ask-job-applicants/) cover logistics in more depth.

What fundraising strategy and planning questions should you ask?

Fundraising strategy questions show whether the candidate can turn a revenue goal into a plan with channels, targets, a budget and a timeline. Strong candidates talk about revenue mix and risk, not only about activity.

  1. Walk me through the last annual fundraising plan you wrote. What was the goal and how did you split it across channels?
  2. How do you set a realistic fundraising goal for next year?
  3. If 60% of our revenue came from one funder and that funder left, what would you do in the first 90 days?
  4. How do you decide how much budget to put into acquisition versus retention?
  5. What does a healthy cost to raise a dollar look like for an organization our size, and how do you measure it?
  6. How would you write a case for support for our organization after reading our website and annual report?
  7. What would you want to achieve in your first year in this role, and how would we know?

Revenue mix is a fair test right now. Giving USA 2026 reported that Americans gave $617 billion in 2025, up 3% after inflation, but individuals' share of giving has fallen to 64% from 80% in 1985 while bequests rose by nearly 17%. A candidate who plans for that shift is thinking about where money will come from next, not only where it came from last year.

Which donor pipeline and stewardship questions reveal real experience?

Donor pipeline questions show whether the candidate can move people from a first gift to loyal, growing support. Listen for a system: how prospects are found, how many touches a donor gets, who thanks them and how fast, and how the candidate knows retention is improving.

  1. How do you identify new prospects, and what research do you do before the first meeting?
  2. Describe your stewardship plan for a first-time donor in their first 90 days.
  3. What was your donor retention rate last year, and what did you do to change it?
  4. Tell me about a time you moved a donor up the giving pyramid. What changed in how you worked with them?
  5. How do you handle a lapsed donor who gave every year and then stopped?
  6. How do you segment donors, and how does your messaging change by segment?
  7. How do you report impact to donors so they see what their gift did?

Retention is where most programs win or lose. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project's Q4 2025 report put overall donor retention at 43.3%, barely up from 43.1%, with fewer donors giving each year. Question 10 is worth asking every candidate: a strong answer gives a number, a cause and a fix.

What major gifts and planned giving questions should you ask?

Major gift questions test whether the candidate can manage a portfolio, size an ask and actually make it. Strong candidates describe preparation, the conversation and the follow-up, and they are comfortable talking about money directly.

  1. Tell me about the largest gift you personally asked for. How did you prepare and what happened?
  2. How do you decide how much to ask a specific donor for?
  3. How many donors are in your current portfolio, and how many meetings do you hold in a typical month?
  4. How do you handle a donor who says "not now" to a major gift request?
  5. How do you introduce planned giving or a bequest conversation without it feeling abrupt?
  6. How do you work with an executive director or CEO on a major ask?

Which data, CRM and reporting questions work best?

Data questions show whether the candidate uses donor records and numbers to make decisions, or only to report after the fact. Every fundraising team runs on a donor database, so ask what they built, cleaned and changed because of a report.

  1. Which donor database or CRM have you used, and what did you change in how it was set up?
  2. Which fundraising metrics do you track each month, and which one do you watch most closely?
  3. How do you forecast revenue for the year, and how accurate was your last forecast?
  4. How do you keep donor records accurate, and who owns data entry on your team?
  5. Tell me about a report that changed a decision. What was the decision?
  6. How do you protect sensitive donor information such as contact details and giving history?

What events, campaigns and digital fundraising questions should you ask?

Event and campaign questions test planning, budget control and the ability to turn attention into gifts. Ask for net revenue, not gross, and for what the candidate would change next time.

  1. Tell me about a fundraising event you ran. What did it cost, what did it net and would you run it again?
  2. How do you decide whether an event is worth the staff time it takes?
  3. Which digital channels have raised the most money for you, and how did you measure it?
  4. Describe a year-end appeal you planned. What did you test and what did you learn?
  5. How have you used peer-to-peer or giving day campaigns, and what made them work or fail?

Which grants and corporate partnership questions should you ask?

Grant and partnership questions test writing, research and the discipline to report on time. They matter most when institutional funders make up a large share of revenue.

  1. Walk me through a grant proposal you wrote that was funded. What made it strong?
  2. How do you manage reporting deadlines and restricted funds across several grants?
  3. How do you find and approach a company for a sponsorship or partnership that fits our mission?
  4. Tell me about a grant you lost. What did the funder's feedback teach you?

Which leadership, board and team questions show a good fundraising manager?

Leadership questions show whether the candidate can get results through other people: staff, volunteers, the executive director and the board. Fundraising managers who cannot engage a board usually end up raising the whole goal alone.

  1. How do you set goals for each fundraiser on your team and review progress?
  2. How do you work with board members without chasing them for reports?
  3. How would you get a less engaged board member to open one introduction this quarter?
  4. Describe the ideal working relationship between a fundraising manager and the executive director.
  5. How do you recruit, train and keep volunteers involved in fundraising?
  6. How do you coach a fundraiser who has missed target two quarters in a row?

Which behavioral fundraising interview questions show judgment under pressure?

Behavioral questions ask for real past situations, which show how the candidate behaves when a plan fails. Use the situation, action and result structure, and ask follow-up questions until you hear numbers.

  1. Tell me about a campaign that missed its goal. What did you do and what would you change?
  2. Describe a time you had to win back a donor who was unhappy with the organization.
  3. Tell me about a time two priorities collided, such as a gala and a grant deadline in the same week.
  4. Describe a time you disagreed with a leader about a fundraising approach. How was it resolved?
  5. Tell me about a time a donor said no. What did you learn and what happened next?

What ethics and compliance questions should fundraising candidates answer?

Ethics questions test whether the candidate will protect the organization's reputation when money is on the table. Ask them to every fundraising candidate, at every level. The AFP Code of Ethical Standards, which many fundraisers know well, is a useful reference for what good answers include.

  1. A donor offers a large gift with conditions that do not fit our mission. What do you do?
  2. How do you make sure restricted gifts are used only for what the donor intended, and that every gift is acknowledged correctly?
  3. What would you do if a colleague shared donor information outside the organization?
  4. How do you decide whether to accept a gift from a source that could harm our reputation?

Compliance basics belong in this section too. In the US, the IRS requires a written acknowledgment for any single contribution of $250 or more, stating the amount and whether the donor received anything in return, such as a gala dinner. A fundraising manager who runs events and donor programs should know that rule without looking it up.

Fundraising manager interview questions and answers: what does a strong answer sound like?

A strong answer to a fundraising manager interview question describes a specific situation, the candidate's own actions, a measured result and what they learned. The six worked examples below show what to listen for, a sample answer and the red flag for some of the most useful questions above.

How do you decide how much to ask a specific donor for?

Look for: Research on capacity and interest, giving history, a gift table or range, and a plan for the follow-up.

Example answer: "I look at the donor's giving history with us and others, any wealth screening, and what they care about most in our work. I set an ask at the top of a realistic range and tie it to one project. For a donor giving $5,000 a year I asked for $25,000 over two years for a scholarship fund, and agreed $20,000."

Red flag: "I let the donor tell me what they want to give." No preparation and no ask.

What was your donor retention rate last year, and what did you do to change it?

Look for: A number, a cause and a fix, plus a separate view of first-time and repeat donors.

Example answer: "Overall retention was 41%, but first-time donors renewed at only 22%. We added a thank-you call within 48 hours and an impact email at 60 days for every new donor. First-year retention rose to 30% the next year."

Red flag: No number, or "we send a newsletter" as the whole stewardship plan.

Tell me about a campaign that missed its goal. What did you do?

Look for: Honest ownership, a clear reason, a mid-course change and a lesson applied later.

Example answer: "Our spring appeal was 30% behind at the halfway point because our email list had decayed. I shifted budget to phone calls to lapsed donors and a board match. We finished at 88% of goal, and I started a list clean-up every quarter."

Red flag: Blaming the economy or the board, with nothing the candidate did differently.

How do you work with board members without chasing them for reports?

Look for: Specific, small asks matched to each member, a development committee, and shared ownership of the plan.

Example answer: "I meet each board member once a year to agree one or two things they will do, such as three introductions or hosting a dinner. The development committee reviews progress each quarter, so peers hold each other to it."

Red flag: "The board does not really fundraise." No plan to change that.

Which fundraising metrics do you track each month?

Look for: Revenue against goal, retention, average gift, pipeline value, cost to raise a dollar, and what they do when a metric slips.

Example answer: "I track revenue against plan by channel, donor retention, average gift, and the value of open major gift proposals. If pipeline value drops below three times the remaining goal, I add discovery meetings for the next month."

Red flag: Only total dollars raised, with no leading indicators.

A donor offers a large gift with conditions that do not fit our mission. What do you do?

Look for: Reference to the gift acceptance policy, escalation to leadership, and a willingness to turn money down.

Example answer: "I would thank the donor, check the conditions against our gift acceptance policy and take it to the executive director. If we could not reshape the gift to fit the mission, I would decline politely and keep the relationship open."

Red flag: "A gift is a gift. We can figure out the details later."

Pro tip: Ask for numbers on every answer: portfolio size, gift amounts, retention rates, the timeline. Experienced fundraisers know their numbers; vague answers usually mean the candidate supported the work rather than led it.

How should you score answers to fundraising manager interview questions?

Score each answer from 1 to 5 against anchors written before the first interview, and have every interviewer score on their own before the debrief. A shared scale makes candidates comparable and keeps the decision tied to evidence, not to whoever was most charming in the room.

A 1 to 5 scorecard for rating answers to fundraising manager interview questions

An [interview scorecard](/what-is-an-interview-scorecard/) keeps these anchors in one place, and a [structured interview](/structured-interview-why-they-work-and-how-to-conduct/) format makes sure every candidate hears the same questions.

What red flags show up in fundraising manager interviews?

The most common red flags in fundraising manager interviews are vague answers with no numbers and no clear ownership. Watch for these:

  • No numbers: Cannot say their last goal, portfolio size, retention rate or largest gift.
  • "Relationships" with no system: Talks about building relationships but has no plan for moves, touches or stewardship.
  • Never makes the ask: Describes cultivation in detail but cannot describe asking for a gift.
  • No view of the board: Treats the board as a problem rather than a partner to engage.
  • Blames others: Explains every missed goal by the economy, the board or marketing.
  • Loose on ethics: Would accept any gift, or shares donor data casually.

For more general warning signs, see these [interview red flags](/interview-red-flags-candidates/).

When should a fundraising skills test come before the interview?

A fundraising skills test should come before the interview whenever you have more applicants than you can interview well. A short test of fundraising knowledge, writing and data skills filters the shortlist, so the panel spends its time on judgment, ethics and fit.

A four-step fundraising manager hiring flow: skills test, structured interview, work sample and scored debrief
  1. Skills test: Use the [Fundraiser test](/test-library/fundraiser/) with a [business communication test](/test-library/business-communication/) or a [data analysis test](/test-library/data-analysis/) for data-heavy roles.
  2. Structured interview: Ask 8 to 12 questions from the sections above, the same for every candidate.
  3. Work sample: Ask for a one-page appeal letter, a gift table for a sample campaign, or a short plan to re-engage lapsed donors.
  4. Scored debrief: Each interviewer shares scores and evidence before opinions.

Talent teams see the same pattern across roles. LinkedIn's Future of Recruiting 2025 found that 93% of talent acquisition professionals say accurately assessing a candidate's skills is crucial for improving quality of hire, and companies that run the most skills-based searches are 12% more likely to make a quality hire.

Testlify lets you build an assessment from your job description, pick from 3,500+ tests and run AI interviews by video, voice or [chat](/chat-ai-interviews/), with 20+ proctoring checks and results that sync to 100+ ATS and HRIS tools. For mission-driven teams, the [non-profit plan](/non-profits/) includes a discount, and our guide to [pre-hire assessments for the nonprofit sector](/pre-hire-assessments-for-nonprofit-sector/) covers other roles you may be hiring for.

Ready to hire your next fundraising manager?

Pick 8 to 12 fundraising manager interview questions from the sections that match your role, write your 1 to 5 anchors and put a fundraising skills test in front of the interview. Browse fundraising and communication tests in the [Testlify test library](/test-library/), start a 7-day free trial with no credit card, or [book a demo](/book-a-demo/) to see how skills tests and AI interviews fit your hiring process.

Frequently asked questions

Yash Patel
Yash Patel

Wordpress Developer

Yash Patel is a Wordpress and SEO Specialist at Testlify with 3+ years of experience in technical SEO, on-page optimization, and content strategy. He works on improving Testlify's organic presence and produces content focused on hiring, talent assessment, and HR technology.

LinkedIn

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.