See what's new

Testlify
HR & recruitment
Last updated on: 12 November 202616 min read

Inclusive hiring process: 7 steps to build a fair one

How to build an inclusive hiring process: job-related criteria, wider sourcing, skills tests, structured interviews, and pass rate checks.

Inclusive hiring process: 7 steps to build a fair one

An inclusive hiring process is a way of recruiting where every candidate can apply, take part and be judged on the same job-related criteria, whatever their background, disability, age or gender. It removes the barriers that screen people out for reasons that have nothing to do with the work, and it checks the results to prove the process is fair.

TL;DR / Key Takeaways

  • An inclusive hiring process judges every candidate on the same job-related criteria, gives everyone equal access to apply and take part, and checks pass rates by group to prove it works.
  • Build it in 7 steps: job-related criteria, inclusive job ads, wider sourcing, blind skills-first screening, structured interviews with mixed panels, interviewer training, and candidate feedback.
  • Skills-based screening widens the pool: LinkedIn's 2025 data shows talent pools grow 6.1x globally and 15.9x in the US when employers hire on skills instead of past job titles.
  • Accessibility is cheap: 61% of employers in Job Accommodation Network data said an accommodation cost nothing, and the median one-time cost was $300.
  • Measure each stage. If one group passes a stage at less than 80% of the rate of the highest group, review that stage.
  • Inclusive hiring is not a quota. In 2026 it means a merit-based, job-related and accessible process, which is also what Title VII, the ADA, NYC Local Law 144 and the EU AI Act expect.
Summarise this post with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

What is an inclusive hiring process?

An inclusive hiring process is a recruitment process designed so that qualified people from every background can find the job, apply, take the assessments and interviews, and be scored fairly. Every stage uses criteria tied to the job, the same questions and scoring for every candidate, and adjustments for people who need them.

Inclusive hiring and diversity hiring are related but not the same. Diversity describes who ends up in your pipeline and your team. Inclusion describes how the process treats people on the way in. A diverse pipeline that goes through a biased interview still produces biased hires, so the process is where the work happens.

An inclusive hiring process is also not about lowering the bar or hiring to a quota. The bar stays the same for everyone; inclusive hiring makes sure the bar measures the job and nothing else. Testlify has a fuller guide to the common types of hiring bias that each step below is designed to remove.

Build your dream team — Book a product demo

Why does an inclusive hiring process matter?

An inclusive hiring process matters because it gives you more qualified candidates to choose from, better hiring decisions and lower legal risk. Most bias in hiring screens out people who could do the job well, so removing it is first a talent problem and only second a reputation one.

  • Bigger talent pools: LinkedIn Economic Graph's 2025 skills-based hiring report found that hiring on skills instead of past job titles expands talent pools 6.1x globally and 15.9x in the US. For AI roles, the same approach could raise the share of women in the pool by up to 24%.
  • Untapped candidates: Workers without a bachelor's degree saw a 6% bigger increase in their talent pool than degree holders under a skills-based model, according to the same LinkedIn report.
  • Better decisions: Structured, job-related criteria make it easier to explain why one candidate was hired over another, to the hiring manager and to a regulator.
  • Candidate trust: Candidates notice when a process is fair. A clear, consistent process reduces drop-off and complaints, which matters most in volume hiring.
  • Lower legal risk: Discrimination laws still apply to every hiring stage, including tests and AI tools. A process you can measure is a process you can defend.

How do you build an inclusive hiring process step by step?

An inclusive hiring process is built in seven steps: set job-related criteria, write inclusive job ads, widen sourcing, screen on skills with personal details hidden, run structured interviews with mixed panels, train the hiring team, and collect candidate feedback. Each step removes one common source of bias.

The 7 steps of an inclusive hiring process, from job-related criteria to candidate feedback

1. Define job-related hiring criteria

Start with a short job analysis: what the person will do in the first year, and which skills, knowledge and behaviors that work needs. Turn that into a list of must-have criteria, each with a way to test it. Drop anything you cannot link to the work, such as a degree for a role that does not need one, years of experience used as a stand-in for skill, or "culture fit".

Replace culture fit with culture add: ask what perspective or skill a candidate would bring that the team lacks. Check that the criteria support the company's goals as well as the team's, so managers do not quietly add their own preferences later.

If you run background or criminal record checks, keep them to what the role legally needs and run them after a conditional offer. Look at the offense, how long ago it happened and what the person has done since, rather than rejecting on the record alone. Fair chance rules differ by city, state and country, so check the rules where you hire.

2. Write inclusive job descriptions

Write the job ad around outcomes and must-have skills, not a wish list. Long lists of nice-to-haves put off qualified candidates who do not tick every box.

  • Neutral language: Avoid gendered or culturally loaded words ("rockstar", "ninja", "aggressive") and say "you" and "they" instead of "he" or "she".
  • Real requirements only: Focus on the essential functions. For a customer service role, ask for clear communication and calm complaint handling, not an "outgoing personality".
  • Pay and flexibility: Show the salary range and any remote or flexible options. Both widen the pool, especially for carers and candidates with disabilities.
  • Accommodation line: Say how to request an adjustment during hiring, with a named contact.
  • Inclusion statement: Add an equal opportunity statement and, if you have them, mention employee resource groups or mentoring programs.

Testlify's guide on how to attract diverse candidates to your job postings has more examples of wording that widens the pool.

3. Widen your sourcing channels

If every hire comes from the same job boards, universities and referrals, the pipeline will look like your current team. Add niche job boards, community groups, disability and veteran organizations, re-entry programs, coding bootcamps and returner programs. Ask employee resource groups to share roles, and treat referrals as one channel among several rather than the main one. Track which channels produce candidates who pass each stage, not just applicants.

4. Screen on skills, with personal details hidden

The first screen is where most bias happens, because reviewers judge resumes in seconds. Two changes make the biggest difference:

  • Blind screening: Hide names, photos, addresses, graduation years and school names during the first review. Testlify's guide to blind hiring covers how to set it up.
  • Skills tests first: Ask every applicant to take the same short, job-related assessment before anyone reads a resume. Candidates are then compared on what they can do, not where they have been.

Design assessments that mirror real tasks: a spreadsheet task for an analyst, a ticket reply for a support agent, a short coding task for a developer. Keep them short and relevant so candidates with less free time, often carers and people already working, are not screened out by the length of the test.

5. Run structured interviews with diverse panels

A structured interview asks every candidate the same job-related questions in the same order and scores each answer against a written rubric. It is one of the simplest ways to cut interviewer bias. Testlify explains how to run one in its guide to structured interviews.

  • Same questions, same time: Give every candidate the same questions and the same amount of time.
  • Score before you talk: Each interviewer scores alone on an interview scorecard before the debrief, so the loudest voice does not set the result.
  • Mixed panels: Include interviewers of different backgrounds, levels and teams. Mixed panels catch blind spots and show candidates who they would work with.
  • No off-script questions: Skip salary history, family plans and "where are you from" questions. Keep small talk out of the score.
Pro tip: Share the interview format, the length and the topics a few days in advance. Candidates who are nervous, neurodivergent or interviewing in a second language perform closer to their real level when they know what to expect.

6. Train your hiring team

Train everyone who screens or interviews on unconscious bias, the scoring rubric, accessible interviewing and which questions are off limits. Include the experiences of underrepresented groups, such as people of color, LGBTQ+ candidates and people with disabilities, so the training is about real situations and not just theory. Repeat it once a year and for every new hiring manager; one session at onboarding fades quickly.

7. Ask candidates for feedback

Send a short anonymous survey to every candidate who reaches the assessment stage, including those you reject. Ask whether the process was clear, whether they could ask for an adjustment and whether the questions felt relevant. Look for patterns by stage and by group, and change the stage that draws the most complaints.

How do you make hiring accessible for candidates with disabilities?

Hiring becomes accessible when candidates with disabilities can apply, take every test and interview, and ask for an adjustment without being judged for it. Accessibility runs through every step above, and it matters: the US Bureau of Labor Statistics reported an 8.3% unemployment rate for people with a disability in 2025, double the 4.1% rate for people without one.

  • Accessible application: Make the careers site and forms work with screen readers and keyboards, and offer a second way to apply.
  • Ask everyone: Put an accommodation request option in every invite, so candidates do not have to disclose a disability to ask.
  • Common adjustments: Extra time on a test, a different format, captions, a sign language interpreter, a quiet room or a written copy of interview questions.
  • Same standard: Adjust how the skill is tested, not the skill you are testing for.

Most adjustments cost little. According to the Job Accommodation Network, 61% of employers who shared cost data said their accommodation cost nothing, and the median one-time cost was $300. The HR glossary explains the Job Accommodation Network and what counts as a reasonable accommodation.

How do skills assessments make hiring more inclusive?

Skills assessments make hiring more inclusive because every candidate answers the same job-related tasks and is scored the same way, before anyone sees a name, school or employer. Decisions rest on what a person can do, which opens the door to career changers, people without degrees and candidates from overlooked schools. The idea behind it is skills-based hiring.

Testlify is an AI-native skills assessment and interviewing platform built for this kind of process:

  • Test library: 3,500+ tests for technical and non-technical roles, including role-specific, cognitive ability, situational judgment, language and software skills tests.
  • Same test for every candidate: The AI test builder turns a job description into a role-specific assessment, so every applicant for the role gets the same questions and automated scoring.
  • Structured AI interviews: One-way video and audio interviews and two-way AI interviews ask every candidate the same questions and score each answer against the same criteria, with a person making the final call.
  • Language access: Candidates can take assessments in 15+ languages, which helps when you hire across regions.
  • Fair conditions: 20+ proctoring checks, including question randomization, keep results honest without singling anyone out. See anti-cheating and proctoring.
  • Third-party audit: The Matching Model behind Testlify passed an independent NYC Local Law 144 bias audit, completed June 16, 2023.
Key takeaway: A test does not make hiring fair on its own. Pick tests that match the job, give everyone the same conditions, offer adjustments, and check pass rates by group.

How do you measure whether your hiring process is inclusive?

You measure an inclusive hiring process by tracking how candidates from each group move through every stage, and checking where the gaps open. Collect demographic data voluntarily and keep it apart from the people making hiring decisions, then compare pass rates stage by stage every quarter.

Metric

What it shows

When to act

Applicant mix by channel

Whether sourcing reaches new groups

One channel supplies most hires

Pass rate by group at each stage

Where candidates drop out

A group passes at under 80% of the top group's rate

Accommodation requests and turnaround

Whether adjustments are easy to get

Requests take more than 2 working days

Interview score spread by interviewer

Interviewers who score harder or softer

One interviewer is far off the panel average

Offer acceptance by group

Whether offers and pay land fairly

Acceptance gap between groups

Candidate feedback score

How fair the process feels

Low scores at one stage

First-year retention by group

Whether inclusion lasts after the hire

Early leavers cluster in one group

The pass rate check comes from the US four-fifths rule. Under the Uniform Guidelines on Employee Selection Procedures, 29 CFR 1607.4, a selection rate for any group that is less than four-fifths (80%) of the rate for the highest group is generally treated as evidence of adverse impact.

Worked example of the four-fifths rule check on a skills test stage of an inclusive hiring process

Here is how the check works on one stage. Group A: 200 candidates took the skills test and 80 passed, a 40% pass rate. Group B: 120 took it and 36 passed, a 30% pass rate. Divide 30% by 40% and you get 75%, below the 80% line, so the test needs a review: is every question tied to the job, is the time limit fair, and were adjustments offered? With small numbers, look at the trend over several hiring rounds before you change anything.

How do you use AI in hiring without adding bias?

AI can make hiring more consistent, because it applies the same criteria to every candidate, but it can also repeat old bias at scale if it learns from past decisions. Use AI to structure and score, and keep people responsible for the decision.

  • Score against job criteria: Use tools that score answers against criteria you set for the role, not tools that copy who you hired before.
  • Human review: A trained person reviews AI scores and makes every final decision.
  • Audit regularly: Check pass rates by group for every AI-scored stage, using the same four-fifths check.
  • Tell candidates: Explain where AI is used and how to ask for an alternative or an adjustment.

Some cities already require this. Under New York City's Local Law 144, employers cannot use an automated employment decision tool unless it had a bias audit within the past year, a summary of the results is public, and candidates get notice 10 business days before it is used.

What laws shape an inclusive hiring process in 2026?

The laws that shape an inclusive hiring process in 2026 are mostly anti-discrimination and accessibility laws, plus new rules on AI in hiring. None of them require quotas; all of them expect hiring decisions based on job-related criteria and equal access.

  • United States: Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act and the ADA apply to every stage, including tests. The ADA requires reasonable accommodations during hiring. Executive Order 14173, signed in January 2025, revoked the affirmative action requirements of Executive Order 11246 for federal contractors, but the anti-discrimination laws still apply. That is why a merit-based, job-related process is the safest design.
  • New York City: Local Law 144 requires bias audits and candidate notice for automated hiring tools.
  • United Kingdom: The Equality Act 2010 protects nine characteristics and requires reasonable adjustments for disabled candidates.
  • European Union: The EU AI Act lists AI used in employment, such as CV-sorting software, as high-risk. According to the European Commission, the high-risk rules for these systems apply from 2 December 2027, and the transparency rules from August 2026.

Laws differ by country and state, so confirm the rules with your legal team before you change a hiring stage.

What are the common challenges and how do you fix them?

The most common challenges are unconscious bias, a narrow talent pool, resistance from hiring managers and too little data to measure progress. Each one has a practical fix.

Challenge

What it looks like

Fix

Unconscious bias

Interviewers favor candidates like themselves

Structured interviews, solo scoring, bias training

Narrow talent pool

Same schools and referrals every time

New sourcing partners, skills-first screening, no unneeded degree rules

Resistance to change

Managers see structure as slower

Show time saved and better hires from a pilot role

"Culture fit" rejections

Vague reasons for saying no

Culture add criteria, written reasons tied to the rubric

Inaccessible steps

Drop-off at tests or video interviews

Accommodation line in every invite, accessible formats

Too little data

No pass rates by group

Voluntary self-ID survey, quarterly stage review

What should an inclusive hiring checklist include?

An inclusive hiring checklist should cover every stage, from the job ad to the first year. Use this one before each new role opens:

  • Criteria: Must-have skills listed and each linked to a test or interview question.
  • Job ad: Neutral language, salary range, flexible options, accommodation contact, equal opportunity statement.
  • Sourcing: At least two channels beyond your usual job board and referrals.
  • Screening: Personal details hidden at first review, same skills test for every applicant.
  • Interviews: Same questions, written rubric, solo scoring, mixed panel.
  • Accessibility: Adjustment option in every invite, accessible test and interview formats.
  • AI tools: Bias audit, human review, candidate notice.
  • Measurement: Pass rates by group at each stage, candidate survey, quarterly review.

Build a fairer shortlist with Testlify

An inclusive hiring process works best when every candidate takes the same job-related test before anyone reads a resume. Browse the Testlify test library to find tests for your open roles, or start a 7-day free trial, no credit card needed, and build your first skills-based assessment from a job description.

Frequently asked questions

Yashika Khandelwal
Yashika Khandelwal

Content Writer

Yashika Khandelwal is a Content Writer with 3+ years of experience creating research-backed content on hiring, talent assessment, and HR technology. She is a registered Organizational Psychologist and subject matter expert who combines behavioral science with practical recruitment insights to produce accurate, evidence-based content.

LinkedIn

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.