Contrast Effect

What is the contrast effect?

The contrast effect is a psychological phenomenon where our perception of something is influenced by comparing it to something else. For instance, if you hear a bad song, a decent one right after might seem much better than it actually is. This bias can affect how we judge things like job candidates or options in decision-making.

In hiring, hiring managers may unconsciously compare one candidate to another, rather than evaluating each based on their own qualifications. This can lead to biases. Recognizing the contrast effect helps ensure fairer evaluations in processes like recruitment, where decisions should be based on job descriptions rather than comparisons.

Recruitment contrast effect

The contrast effect can impact how job candidates are evaluated during the hiring process. This effect happens when a recruiter compares candidates to each other, rather than judging each one individually.

For example, if a candidate follows someone who performed very well, the next person might seem less qualified than they truly are. On the flip side, a weaker candidate interviewed earlier could make the next one seem much stronger, even if their true quality isn’t as high.

To avoid this cognitive bias, recruiters should focus on each candidate’s skills and qualifications independently. This ensures that the best candidate is chosen based on their actual fit for the role, not in comparison to others.

Integrating strategies like structured interview questions or standardized evaluations can help eliminate these unconscious biases. This allows hiring managers to make decisions based on a candidate’s merits rather than the contrast effect.

Impacts of the contrast effect

The contrast effect is a cognitive bias that influences how we perceive things. It occurs when we compare one thing to another, altering our judgment. Here are some ways it can affect decision-making:

1. Biased evaluations

The contrast effect can make us see something as better or worse than it is. This happens because we compare it to something else. For example, if we evaluate job candidates, the best candidate might seem even more impressive when compared to weaker candidates.

2. Over or under estimation

We can also over- or under-estimate something’s value due to the contrast effect. For instance, if we are presented with two options, one might seem less appealing just because the other one is significantly better.

3. Unfair comparisons

Sometimes we compare things to the wrong reference point. This can lead to unfair comparisons. For example, in the hiring process, if a recruiter uses one strong candidate as a benchmark, other good candidates might be undervalued.

The contrast effect can distort our judgment, especially in areas like hiring or decision-making. Hiring managers should be aware of how unconscious biases like this can affect their choices. Being mindful of this cognitive bias can lead to more accurate assessments and better decisions.

Contrast effect examples

The contrast effect can appear in various scenarios, especially in hiring processes. Here are some examples:

• Job candidates: If a recruiter interviews a highly qualified candidate first, the second option or subsequent candidates may seem less impressive by comparison, even if they are well-qualified.
• Interview performance: If one candidate answers all the interview questions perfectly, another candidate’s responses may seem weaker, even if they are good answers on their own.
• Job descriptions: When comparing two job descriptions, one might seem less appealing, depending on how the other is framed, even though both may offer similar roles and benefits.

These examples show how the contrast effect can skew evaluations in hiring situations.

How to prevent the contrast effect from affecting hiring?

To avoid falling into the contrast effect trap during the hiring process, here are some strategies:

1. Standardize evaluation criteria: Use the same criteria to evaluate candidates, regardless of the order in which they’re interviewed. This ensures you assess everyone against the same standards.
2. Avoid immediate comparisons: Give yourself time between interviews to focus on each candidate independently. This reduces the risk of comparing them directly to the previous interviewee.
3. Use structured interviews: Asking the same set of interview questions to each candidate helps maintain consistency and prevents bias from creeping in.
4. Focus on true quality: Remember that the contrast effect can distort how you view someone. Try to focus on each candidate’s true quality and skills.

By implementing these practices, hiring managers can make more objective decisions and reduce the influence of the contrast effect during the recruitment process.