What are bumping rights?

Bumping Rights, also known as Displacement Rights or Recall Rights, refer to the rights of employees to reclaim their jobs or to be placed in a similar position if their job is eliminated or they are laid off due to a reduction in the workforce.

Image showing the meaning of bumping rights

These rights typically allow more senior employees to displace less senior employees in the same or similar job classification as long as the more senior employee is qualified to perform the position’s duties.

Bumping Rights are often included in collective bargaining agreements between unions and employers and can vary depending on the specific terms of the agreement.

In the context of organizations, Bumping Rights can be a way to protect the job security of employees and ensure that layoffs are implemented fairly.

Essential features of bumping rights

There are several essential features of bumping rights that are commonly found in collective bargaining agreements, as mentioned below:

  1. Seniority: Bumping Rights are typically based on seniority, which means that more senior employees have priority over less senior employees in terms of reclaiming or being placed in a similar position.
  2. Qualifications: An employee must be qualified to perform the duties of the position they are seeking to bump into.
  3. Classification: Bumping rights typically apply to employees in the same job classification or a similar classification.
  4. Scope: The scope of bumping rights can vary depending on the agreement. In some cases, bumping rights may apply only to a specific location or department, while in others they may be more broadly applicable.
  5. Duration: Bumping rights may be temporary or permanent, depending on the specific terms of the agreement.
  6. Notice: Employees who are displaced or laid off due to a reduction in workforce are typically entitled to advance notice and may have the right to bump into another position during the notice period.
Banner 4

Pros and cons of bumping rights

Here are some potential Pros and Cons of Bumping Rights:

Pros:

  • These rights can provide job security and stability for employees, especially those with more seniority.
  • These rights can encourage employees to develop skills and expertise in their job classification, as they know that their seniority may give them an advantage in the event of a reduction in workforce.
  • These rights can help to ensure that layoffs are implemented fairly, as more senior employees have priority over less senior employees in terms of reclaiming or being placed in a similar position.

Cons:

  • These rights may discourage employers from hiring new employees or promoting from within, as they may be required to lay off more senior employees before considering less senior employees for layoffs.
  • These rights may create a sense of entitlement among employees, leading to a lack of motivation to improve or develop new skills.
  • These rights may lead to resentment among employees who are displaced by more senior employees, negatively impacting morale.
  • These rights may make it more difficult for employers to respond to changing business needs, as they may be limited in their ability to make changes to their workforce.

What are the different types of bumping rights?

There are several types of bumping rights that may be included in collective bargaining agreements as mentioned below:

  1. Horizontal bumping: This refers to the right of an employee to bump into a position in the same job classification or a similar classification.
  2. Vertical bumping: This refers to the right of an employee to bump into a position in a lower job classification, typically at a reduced rate of pay.
  3. Recall rights: This refers to the right of an employee to reclaim their job if it becomes available again after a layoff.
  4. Displacement rights: This refers to the right of an employee to be placed in a similar position if their job is eliminated or they are laid off due to a reduction in workforce.
  5. Layoff bumping: This refers to the right of an employee to bump into a position held by another employee who is being laid off.
  6. Transfer bumping: This refers to the right of an employee to bump into a position at a different location or in a different department.