What is a position review?

A position review is a process of evaluating the role and responsibilities of a specific job within an organization. It typically includes an assessment of the duties, skills, qualifications, and performance requirements of the position, as well as the overall alignment of the role with the organization’s goals and objectives.

Image showing the meaning of position review

The goal of a Position Review is to ensure that the position is effective in meeting the needs of the organization, and to identify any areas that need improvement or adjustment.

The process can include input from the employee holding the position, their supervisor, and other relevant stakeholders, and can be done periodically or as part of a larger organizational review process.

Process of position review

The process of a Position Review typically involves the following steps:

  1. Preparation: The organization or HR department will gather information about the position and the employee, including any relevant job descriptions, performance evaluations, and other relevant documentation.
  2. Job analysis: This step involves analyzing the duties, responsibilities, and requirements of the position. This can include interviews with the employee, their supervisor, and other relevant stakeholders, as well as a review of any relevant documentation or reports.
  3. Performance evaluation: The employee’s performance in the role is assessed, including their skills, knowledge, and experience, as well as their ability to meet the requirements of the position. This can include a review of the employee’s job performance, as well as any relevant metrics or data.
  4. Alignment with organizational goals: The position is evaluated in terms of how it aligns with the organization’s overall mission, vision, and objectives. This includes an assessment of how the role supports the organization’s strategic goals, as well as its ability to meet the needs of internal and external customers.
  5. Identification of improvement areas: Any areas where the position or the employee’s performance could be improved or enhanced are identified. This can include areas related to skills, knowledge, or experience, as well as areas related to the structure or design of the position itself.
  6. Recommendations: Proposals for changes or improvements to the position or the employee’s performance, along with a plan for implementing those recommendations, are made.
  7. Follow-up: A plan for monitoring the progress of the changes and improvements, and assessing their effectiveness in achieving the desired outcomes is established.
  8. Communication: The results of the position review and any proposed changes or improvements will be communicated to the employee, their supervisor, and any other relevant stakeholders.
Banner 4

What are the different types of position reviews?

There are several types of position reviews, which can vary depending on the organization and the nature of the role:

  1. Annual performance review: This type of review is typically conducted on an annual basis and focuses on the employee’s performance over the past year. It includes an assessment of the employee’s performance against established goals and objectives, and may include feedback from supervisors, peers, and subordinates.
  2. 360-degree review: This type of review involves feedback from multiple sources, including supervisors, peers, subordinates, and customers or clients. It provides a more comprehensive view of the employee’s performance and can help identify areas for improvement.
  3. Job shadowing: This type of review involves observing an employee as they perform their job duties. It can help to identify areas where an employee may need additional training or support, as well as areas where the job itself may need to be redesigned.
  4. Organizational review: This type of review is conducted as part of a larger organizational review process, and may involve an assessment of the overall structure and design of the organization, as well as the roles and responsibilities of individual positions.
  5. Promotional review: This type of review is conducted when an employee is being considered for a promotion. It evaluates the employee’s qualifications, skills, and experience for the new role, as well as their performance in their current role.
  6. Exit review: This type of review is conducted when an employee is leaving the organization, either voluntarily or involuntarily. It evaluates the employee’s performance, contributions, and reasons for leaving, and provide feedback for future improvements.

Pros and cons of a position review

The pros and cons of a Position Review will depend on the specific type of review and the organization’s goals and objectives.

Pros of position review:

  • Provides a clear and objective evaluation of an employee’s performance and qualifications.
  • Identifies areas for improvement and development, which can lead to better performance and productivity.
  • Helps to ensure that the position is effectively meeting the needs of the organization.
  • Helps to ensure that the employee is aware of their performance, and the progress they made in their role.
  • Helps to identify the areas where an employee needs additional support and resources.

Cons of position review:

  • It can be time-consuming and resource-intensive for both the employee and the organization.
  • It can be stressful and anxiety-provoking for employees.
  • It can be difficult to gather feedback from multiple sources, particularly in a remote work environment.
  • It can lead to a lack of trust and communication between the employee and the organization.
  • It can create a feeling of insecurity and uncertainty among employees.