See what's new

Testlify
HR & recruitment
Last updated on: 5 October 202611 min read

Types of interviews: A complete HR guide

Discover the different types of interviews in HRM, their formats, best practices, and key strategies to assess candidates effectively for better hiring decisions.

Types of interviews: A complete HR guide

The interview is where a promising resume either becomes a qualified hire or falls apart under scrutiny. The purpose of an interview is to collect job-relevant evidence about whether someone can do a specific job, under conditions consistent enough that two different interviewers would reach the same conclusion.

Yet, using the same interview format for every role can leave recruiters with an incomplete picture of a candidate’s skills, behavior, and potential. That is why understanding the different types of interviews matters.

In this guide, we’ll explore the most common types of interviews, when to use them, what each one measures, and how to choose the right format for your hiring process.

TL;DR

  • An interview exists to produce evidence for one decision: can this person do this job, in this context, better than the other shortlisted candidates.
  • The objectives break into five jobs: verify the record, test judgment, check the work matches, give the candidate a real basis to choose, and leave an auditable trail.
  • Structure is the whole difference. Decades of selection research keep placing structured interviews among the strongest predictors of job performance and unstructured ones well below.
  • Which type of interview you run is a decision about what evidence you need, not a matter of taste or tradition.
  • An interview that leaves no written, comparable record hasn't done its job, however good the conversation felt at the time.
Summarise this post with:ChatGPTGeminiClaudeGrokPerplexity

What is the purpose of an interview?

The purpose of an interview is to gather job-relevant evidence from a candidate under conditions consistent enough to compare one person against another. It verifies what a resume claims, tests judgment that a test alone cannot reach, and gives the candidate what they need to decide about you. Done properly, it ends in a written decision you could defend.

That last clause is the one teams skip. A conversation that changes nobody's mind and leaves no record behind has cost two people an hour and produced nothing you can use.

The US Office of Personnel Management defines a structured interview as a method "designed to measure job-related competencies of candidates by systematically inquiring about their behavior in past experiences and/or their proposed behavior in hypothetical situations".

Note what's doing the work there: systematically. Same questions, same order, same rating standard, so that differences in the answers mean something.

And it runs both ways. The candidate is deciding too, which is why clarity about the role, the team and what happens next is part of the purpose rather than a courtesy bolted onto the end.

Build your dream team — Book a product demo

What are the objectives of an interview?

The objectives of an interview are to verify the candidate's record, test their judgment on real problems, confirm the work they'd actually do matches what they want, give them enough to make their own decision, and produce a comparable record for the people who weren't in the room. The key objectives include:

Image showing objectives of an interview

Assessing job fit and competency

Determine whether candidates have the skills and knowledge required for the role. Use role-specific questions to evaluate their ability to perform key responsibilities.

Understanding cultural and organizational fit

Assess whether a candidate’s values, working style, and expectations align with the organization. Focus on how they collaborate, communicate, and adapt.

Predicting future job performance

Explore how candidates handled challenges and made decisions in previous roles. Behavioral and situational questions can provide useful evidence of how they may perform.

Identifying leadership potential

Look for qualities such as accountability, decision-making, communication, and problem-solving. This is especially important when hiring for senior or leadership roles.

Enhancing employee retention

Use interviews to set clear expectations around responsibilities, growth, and workplace culture. This helps candidates make informed decisions and can reduce early turnover.

Understanding candidate motivation

Find out why candidates want the role and what they expect from their next opportunity. This helps recruiters assess whether their goals align with the position.

Supporting workforce planning

Interview results can highlight recurring skill gaps in the talent pool. Organizations can use these insights to improve hiring, training, and future workforce planning.

Strengthening employer branding

Every interview shapes the candidate experience. A professional, transparent, and respectful process can strengthen how candidates perceive the organization.

Improving hiring efficiency

A structured interview keeps the conversation focused on job-relevant criteria. Using consistent questions and scoring criteria also makes candidate comparisons more objective.

Types of interviews and what each is for

Each type of interview is a tool for producing one kind of evidence. Picking by habit, or because the last hire went that way, is how panels end up with four rounds that all test the same thing.

Type of interview

What it is for

Evidence it produces

Typical length

Structured

Comparing candidates fairly on the same criteria

Scored, side-by-side ratings

45 to 60 minutes

Behavioral

Checking how someone has actually worked before

Worked examples against competencies

45 to 60 minutes

Situational

Testing judgment on problems they haven't met yet

Reasoning under a defined scenario

30 to 45 minutes

Technical or task-based

Confirming they can do the work itself

Observed output, code or a finished task

60 to 90 minutes

Phone or video screen

Qualifying a long shortlist cheaply

Basic fit, motivation, logistics

15 to 30 minutes

Panel

Getting several perspectives in one sitting

Cross-functional ratings on one sample

60 minutes

Structured interview

In a structured interview, every candidate gets the same predefined questions, in the same order, and is evaluated against the same scoring criteria. This makes comparisons more consistent and reduces the influence of interviewer bias.

It is one of the most reliable interview formats for making evidence-based hiring decisions. If you improve only one part of your interview process, start by adding more structure.

Related resource: How to conduct a structured job interview

Unstructured interview

An unstructured interview is an open-ended conversation without a fixed set of questions or scoring criteria. It gives interviewers flexibility to follow interesting responses and explore areas that a standardized format might overlook.

However, that flexibility can also introduce inconsistency. Different candidates may be asked different questions, making it harder to compare them objectively.

Related resources: Our guide on structured vs. unstructured interviews explores this tradeoff in greater detail.

Behavioral interview

A behavioral interview uses a candidate’s past experiences to understand how they may respond to similar situations in the future. Candidates are typically asked to describe specific examples using the STAR method: situation, task, action, and result.

This format works best when questions are tied to clearly defined competencies. It helps recruiters assess how candidates have demonstrated skills such as leadership, teamwork, problem-solving, and communication.

Situational interview

Situational interviews present candidates with hypothetical scenarios based on challenges they could face in the role. They are particularly useful when assessing judgment, decision-making, and problem-solving.

They can also help evaluate candidates who have limited experience with a specific situation. However, hypothetical answers may not always reflect how someone would behave when facing the situation in real life.

Related resource: How situational judgement tests find the best fits

Technical and task-based interview

Technical and task-based interviews ask candidates to complete a job-relevant problem, coding exercise, work sample, or practical task. They provide direct evidence of how candidates apply their skills rather than relying entirely on what they say they can do.

The key is to keep the task relevant and reasonably scoped. An unnecessarily long take-home assignment can end up measuring a candidate’s available time rather than their actual ability.

Related resource: How to simplify candidate screening with technical interview questions

Case study interview

Case study interviews give candidates a business problem or realistic scenario to analyze and solve. They are commonly used for consulting, finance, strategy, and other roles that require structured problem solving.

Interviewers can assess how candidates break down complex problems, work with incomplete information, evaluate options, and explain their reasoning.

Related resource: How to evaluate problem solving skills in candidates

Phone and video screening

Phone and video interviews are typically used as an initial screening stage before a more detailed interview. They help recruiters quickly assess basic qualifications, communication skills, availability, and interest in the role.

Video interviews are particularly useful for distributed or global teams because they reduce scheduling and location constraints.

Related resource: How to prevent impostors in video interviews

Panel interview

A panel interview involves multiple interviewers assessing the same candidate, usually at a later stage of the hiring process. It gives the organization perspectives from different stakeholders without requiring several separate interviews.

However, group dynamics can influence individual judgments. Having each interviewer score the candidate independently before discussing their assessment can make the process more objective.

Related resource: How to conduct an effective job interview

Group interview

A group interview assesses multiple candidates at the same time, often through a shared discussion, exercise, or problem solving activity. It can reveal how candidates communicate, collaborate, influence others, and respond to different personalities.

The format can be particularly useful for roles that require strong teamwork or interpersonal skills. However, recruiters should avoid favoring candidates simply because they are more vocal, as quieter candidates may demonstrate equally valuable abilities.

Key aspects to assess during interviews

A strong interview should go beyond a candidate’s resume and years of experience. Recruiters should focus on the skills, behaviors, and qualities that indicate whether someone can succeed in the role.

Image showing key aspects employers must evaluate during an interview

Communication skills

Assess how clearly candidates express ideas and interact with others by looking at:

  • Clarity and confidence
  • Active listening
  • Ability to explain complex ideas

Problem solving

Understand how candidates approach challenges by exploring:

  • Their problem-solving process
  • How they evaluate possible solutions
  • Examples of challenges they have overcome

Critical thinking

Evaluate how candidates analyze information and make decisions by assessing:

  • Reasoning ability
  • Judgment
  • Ability to evaluate different perspectives

Adaptability and willingness to learn

Determine whether candidates can adjust to changing requirements by exploring:

  • How they handle change
  • Examples of learning new skills
  • Their response to feedback

Cultural fit

Assess whether candidates can work effectively within the organization by considering:

  • Working style
  • Collaboration
  • Alignment with organizational values

Job-specific skills

Evaluate whether candidates have the capabilities required for the position by assessing:

  • Technical knowledge
  • Role-specific competencies
  • Practical experience

Behavioral competencies

Understand how candidates are likely to behave at work by exploring:

  • Past workplace situations
  • Conflict management
  • Teamwork and accountability

Career aspirations

Understand whether the opportunity aligns with the candidate’s goals by discussing:

  • Short- and long-term goals
  • Desired career progression
  • Expectations from the role

Ethical judgment and integrity

Assess how candidates respond to sensitive or difficult situations by exploring:

  • Ethical decision-making
  • Accountability
  • How they handle workplace dilemmas

How to run an interview that serves its purpose

Six steps, in order, and the first two are the ones that get skipped:

  1. Name the competencies the role actually requires. Four or five, not twelve.
  2. Write the rating scale, then the questions that feed it. Same questions, same order, for everyone.
  3. Put the cheap evidence first. A skills assessment before the first call means the interview spends its hour on judgment rather than on verifying whether someone can do the basics.
  4. Run the round. Take notes on what the candidate said, not on how it felt.
  5. Rate independently, before the debrief. Then compare and argue about the gaps.
  6. Tell the candidate what happens next, with a date. This is where most processes lose people they'd already decided to hire.

Ready to put structured evidence in front of your next interview round?

Book a demo, and we'll walk through how assessments, AI interviews, and reviewer scorecards fit the process you already run.

FAQs

Arushi Shah
Arushi Shah

People and Talent Partner

Arushi Shah runs day-to-day talent acquisition and candidate experience at Testlify. She writes on interviewing, structured hiring, and giving candidates a fair, fast process.

LinkedIn

Get started.

Hire on proof, not resumes.

Run your first skills-based assessment free — no credit card required.

We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, serve personalised ads or content, and analyse our traffic. By clicking "Accept All", you consent to our use of cookies.